Reals and collapsing posets

98 Views Asked by At

Let $M$ be a ctm of $ZFC$, and let $P$ be the poset $\prod_{n<\omega}^{\text{fin}} \text{Coll}(\omega,\aleph_n)$ as computed within $M$.

Let $G$ be $P$-generic over $M$. Let $G^{<n}\times G^{\ge n}$ be the image of $G$ under the natural isomorphism $P\cong P^{<n}\times P^{\ge n}$

Let $X=\bigcup_{n<\omega} \mathcal{P}(\omega)\cap M[G^{< n}]$.

I'd like to show that $X\neq \mathcal{P}(\omega)\cap M[G]$, i.e. there is some subset of $\omega$ in the big generic extension which is not added in any of the smaller ones. I'm puzzled because this forcing adds surjections $\omega\to\aleph_n^M$, so I don't know how to get reals into the mix.

Any hints on how to get started?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

First of all, you really shouldn't be puzzled about how you can get reals! Reals are really easy to build from other data. For instance, given a map $\omega\to\omega_n^M$, you can get a real by composing it with any map $\omega_n^M\to 2$. Basically, the thing to keep in mind is that $M[G]$ doesn't just have $G$ added--it also has lots of other sets which can be "built" from $G$ or which encode the data of $G$ in different ways. A real is just a countable sequence of yes/no choices, and such countable sequences can be encoded inside other objects in tons of ways.

Now, you want a real that is not in $M[G^{<n}]$ for any $n$. Intuitively, this means the real cannot be constructed from finitely many of the surjections $\omega\to\omega_n^M$ which $G$ gives you, but instead can only be constructed if you really have all of them (or at least infinitely many of them). So, how could you define a real that uses data from all of the surjections $\omega\to\omega_n^M$ at once?