Rotation Group of a Soccer Ball

1.1k Views Asked by At

I am attempting to show that a soccer ball cannot have a 60 degree rotational symmetry through a line through the centers of two opposite hexagons. My proof so far:

If it had such a symmetry, let's call it Q, then the order of Q is 6. So then the stabilizer of a particular hexagon contains an element of order 6, which in turn implies the stabilizer must be of at least order 6 as well. Now, if I knew that the orbit of any hexagon is of order 12(which i know, but cannot seem to show), then this would mean by orbit-stabilizer theorem that the order of the entire group of rotations would be at least 72, which contradicts that the group is isomorphic to A5, which is of order 60.

How do I show the orbit of any hexagon is 12?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

The symmetry group is $A_5$, which does not contain an element of order $6$.

5
On

It seems to be easier just to observe that the six sides of one of the hexagons are not all equal -- three of them border on pentagons and three of them border on hexagons. So a 60° rotation like you describe would take pentagons to hexagons and vice versa -- it wouldn't be a symmetry at all.