Separation of variables for the heat equation in polar coordinates

151 Views Asked by At

The heat conduction equation in two space dimensions may be expressed in terms of polar coordinates as $$k(u_{rr} +\dfrac{1}{r} u_r +\dfrac{1}{r^2} u_{θθ}) = u_t.$$ Assuming that $u(r, θ, t) = R(r) \Theta(θ)T (t)$, find ordinary differential equations satisfied by $R(r), \Theta(θ)$, and $T (t)$.

This is question question 49 on page 215 of Vector Calculus by Marsden and Tromba. The given answers are:

$T' + kc_1T = 0, , \Theta'' +c_2\Theta = 0, r^2R' +r R' −c_3R = 0$ for some constants $c_1, c_2$, and $c_3$.

I have managed to get the first two, but not the last equation. I started by writing $$k(R'' \Theta T + \dfrac{1}{r} R' \Theta T + \dfrac{1}{r^2} R \Theta'' T) = R \Theta T'.$$

I then tried to separate variables, to get one side depending on $t$ only and another depending on $(r,\theta)$. This would mean that both sides would be equal to a common constant, according to examples I have seen. This means that I get $$ \dfrac{R'' \Theta + \dfrac{1}{r} R' \Theta + \dfrac{1}{r^2} R \Theta''}{R\Theta} = \dfrac{R''}{R} + \dfrac{1}{r} \dfrac{R'}{R} + \dfrac{1}{r^2} \dfrac{\Theta''}{\Theta} = \dfrac{T'}{kT} = c_1.$$

This gave me the first equation, which is $T' = kc_1 T$. I then get the other equation as $\dfrac{R''}{R} + \dfrac{1}{r} \dfrac{R'}{R} + \dfrac{1}{r^2} \dfrac{\Theta''}{\Theta} = c_1$ or $$r^2 c_1 - r^2 \dfrac{R''}{R} - r\dfrac{R'}{R} = \dfrac{\Theta''}{\Theta} = c_2,$$ so I obtain $\Theta'' = c_2 \Theta$ and $r^2c_1 - r^2 \dfrac{R''}{R} - r\dfrac{R'}{R} = c_2$ which gave me $$r^2 R'' + rR' + c_2R - r^2 Rc_1 = 0. $$ This is somewhat similar to the printed answer, but I got an extra term with $r^2$. Please, could someone let me know where I went wrong? Thank you very much.