Shanks Algorithm for composite orders

358 Views Asked by At

Can the Shanks algorithm for discrete logarithm problem (baby-step/giant-step) be used for composite orders?

According to Wiki, "Usually the baby-step giant-step algorithm is used for groups whose order is prime. If the order of the group is composite then the Pohlig–Hellman algorithm is more efficient."

Is the above statement true? I have been trying to understand why the Shanks algorithm may not be used for composite orders, but I have not been able to figure out the reason.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Shank's algorithm can be used for any group, it does not use any specific properties. The same is true for the Pohlig-Hellman algorithm. Suppose we have a group of order $$r=\prod_ip_i^{e_i},$$ then Shank's algorithm is usually presented to have complexity $O(\sqrt{r})$ (although it really is a time-memory trade-off) while Pohlig-Hellman has complexity $$O\left(\sum_ie_i(\log{r}+\sqrt{p_i})\right).$$ Note that Pohlig-Hellman generally does better for composite order, so there is little reason to use Shank's in that case. For prime order groups Pohlig-Hellman doesn't really do anything, so you can just use Shank's.