Showing that the order of $xyx^{-1}$ equals the order of $y$

650 Views Asked by At

I have just started out learning about groups and I am stuck on trying to solve the following question for a couple of hours now:

Let $G$ be a finite group and $x, y$ be in $G$. Show that order of $xyx^{-1}$ equals order of $y$.

The following is how far I was able to go:

To show that the order of $xyx^{-1}$ equals the order of $y$, I believe all I have to do is show the following:

Show that $(xyx^{-1})^m=y^n$.

$$\underbrace{(xyx^{-1})(xyx^{-1})(xyx^{-1})\cdots(xyx^{-1})}_{m\text{ times}} = (xy^mx^{-1}).$$

Now I have to show that $(xy^mx^{-1}) = y^n$, but I cannot do $xx^{-1}y^m=y^n$ because I don't know if the group is abelian or not.

Before you ask, this is not a homework question.

Thanks!

3

There are 3 best solutions below

5
On

Note that conjugation by an element is a group automorphism of $G$. Now note that group automorphisms (and more generally isomorphisms!) preserve the order.

0
On

So, if I understad correctly, you have shown that $(xyx^{-1})^m=xy^mx^{-1}$. Now, you have almost finished. You have two options:

If $m$ is the order of $y$, then $y^m=1$, and $(xyx^{-1})^m=xy^mx^{-1}=x1x^{-1}=1$, so the order of $xyx^{-1}$ is, at most, the order of $y$.

If $m$ is less than the order of $y$, then $y^m\neq 1$, and then $xy^mx^{-1}\neq 1$, since that would mean either $(1)$ $xy^{m}=x\Leftrightarrow y^m=1$, which you know it is not, or $(2)$ $y^mx^{-1}=x^{-1}\Leftrightarrow y^m=1$, which, again, isn't. Therefore, the order of $xyx^{-1}$ is no less than the order of $y$.

From here, if you know that $ord(xyx^{-1})\leq ord(y)$ and $ord(xyx^{-1})\geq ord(y)$, it must be that $ord(xyx^{-1})=ord(y)$.

0
On

It would be enough to show that $(xyx^{-1})^n = e$ iff $y^n = e$. This follows from noticing that $(xyx^{-1})^n = x y^n x^{-1}$.

Indeed if $y^n = e$ then $x y^n x^{-1}= x x^{-1} = e$. Conversely if $(xyx^{-1})^n = e$ then $x y^n x^{-1} = e$ so multiplying on the right by $x$ and on the left by $x^{-1}$ gives $y^n = x^{-1}x = e$ and we are done.