Solid of revolution using washer method(Gives negative answer)

222 Views Asked by At

My teacher even knew that the answer should not be negative but it turned out to be negative. The given was y=x^2, y=4x-x^2, revolving about the y-axis. Here are some of the solution presented, I hope someone could help me find where I went wrong while solving. Thanks in advance. My teacher can’t even find the error that I have committed.

Edit: As I did the right - left thingy, the answer was -112/3(pi) cu. units.

V=(pi)[(sqrt(y))^2-(sqrt(4-y)+2)^2)]dy

V=(pi)[2y-4sqrt(4-y)-8]dy

V=(pi)[y^2+8/3(4-y)^3/2-8y] limit from 0 to 4 <——already integrated

Applying the limits

V=(pi)[16+8/3(0-8)]

V=-112/3(pi) cu. units. Is there anything done wrong? I hope someone can spot what is wrong. I really need the correct answer utgently. Thanks for those who can help.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

6
On BEST ANSWER

Hint: if you plan on using the $y$-axis as your axis of rotation for the washer method, then you are going to need to integrate with respect to $y$, and you need to solve each of the equations in terms of $x$: $$y = x^2 \implies \pm\sqrt y = x \implies \sqrt y = x \checkmark \qquad\text{(Since we need the right-half)}$$ However, the other equation is not so straightforward. You will need to complete the square to help eliminate one of the $x$'s: $$\begin{align}y &= 4x-x^2\\ &= -(x^2-4x + 4 - 4) \\ &= -(x-2)^2 + 4 \\ \implies y- 4 &= -(x-2)^2\\ \pm\sqrt{4-y} &= x-2 \\ \implies \pm\sqrt{4-y}+2 &= x\\ \implies -\sqrt{4-y}+2 &= x. \qquad\text{(Since we need the left-half)}\end{align}$$

enter image description here

Notice how $\sqrt y = x$ is the rightmost graph and $-\sqrt{4-y}+2 = x$ is the leftmost. You will need to do right - left in your radius function when computing the integral.