Solution of first order inexact differential equation

130 Views Asked by At

I have following differential equation before me: $(2y sin(x)+3y^4 sin(x)cos(x))dx-(4y^3 cos^2(x)+cos(x))dy=0$ It is an inexact differential equation. Its Integrating factor comes out to be $cos(x)$.

New $M= 2ysin(x)cos(x)+3y^4sin(x)cos^2(x)$

New $N= -(4y^3cos^3(x)+cos^2(x))$ When I integrate $M$ treating $y$ as a constant, there are more than one way of doing this.

The term $2sin(x)cos(x)$ in $M$ can be integrated to give either $sin^2(x)$ or $-cos(2x)/2$ which differ by a constant. Also in $N$,$cos^2(x)$ could be written either as $1-sin^2(x)$ or $(1+cos(2x))/2$ giving the terms which do not contain $x$ as either $1$ or $1/2$.

All these integrands yield different solutions. I am confused as to which one of these is the correct solution? Are all of them correct?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

10
On

$$-\dfrac {\cos (2x) }2=\dfrac 12 (2\cos^2 x-1)=\dfrac 12(1-2\sin^2 x)$$ All the constants are absorbed by the constant on the right side of the solution: $$F(x,y)=C$$


$$(2y \sin(x)+3y^4 \sin(x)\cos(x))dx-(4y^3 \cos^2(x)+\cos(x))dy=0$$ $$y d(\cos^2x)+y^4 d(\cos^3(x))+ \cos^3(x)dy^4+cos^2(x)dy=0$$ $$ d(y\cos^2x)+d(y^4\cos^3(x))=0$$ After integration: $$\boxed {y\cos^2x+y^4\cos^3(x)=K}$$

The constant on the right side absorbs all the constants so all the solutions are equivalent and correct.


I am not sure to clearly understand the problem but let's integrate the way you did: $$M= 2y\sin(x)\cos(x)+3y^4\sin(x)\cos^2(x)$$ We have that $$\partial_x F=M$$ $$F= \int Mdx$$ $$F=\int 2y\sin(x)\cos(x)+3y^4\sin(x)\cos^2(x)dx$$ Don't forget the constant of integration: $$F=y\sin^2(x)-y^4\cos^3(x)+\color{red}{g(y)}$$ $$F=-y\cos^2(x)-y^4\cos^3(x)+\color{red}{g(y)+y}$$ $$F=-y\cos^2(x)-y^4\cos^3(x)+\color{red}{h(y)}$$ Do the same for $N$: $$F =\int -(4y^3\cos^3(x)+\cos^2(x))dy$$ $$F = -y^4\cos^3(x)-y\cos^2(x) +\color {green}{r(x)}$$

From these two equations about $F$ we deduce that $h(y)=r(x)=c$. So that the solution is now: $$F(x,y)=K$$ $$y^4\cos^3(x)+y\cos^2(x) =\color {green}{C}$$ It ends with the same answer as we find before.

0
On

Too long for a comment.

Consider the implicit function $$f(x,y)= y\cos^2(x)+y^4\cos^3(x)-k=0$$ as given by @Aryadeva. Then $$\frac{\partial f(x,y)}{\partial x}=-y \sin (x) \cos (x) \left(3 y^3 \cos (x)+2\right)$$ $$\frac{\partial f(x,y)}{\partial y}=\cos ^2(x) \left(4 y^3 \cos (x)+1\right)$$ $$y'=\frac{dy}{dx}=-\frac{\frac{\partial f(x,y)}{\partial x} } {\frac{\partial f(x,y)}{\partial y} }=\frac{y \sin (x) \left(3 y^3 \cos (x)+2\right)}{\cos (x) \left(4 y^3 \cos (x)+1\right)}$$ Plug this in the equation $$(2y \sin(x)+3y^4 \sin(x)\cos(x))-(4y^3 \cos^2(x)+\cos(x))\,y'=0$$ to get $0=0$.