Square in narrow ideal class group?

178 Views Asked by At

This is related to Chpt 5, Sec 1(Quadratic Residue) Algebraic Number Theory by Taylor Frohlich

Narrow ideal class group is defined by quotient $C^+=\frac{I}{P^+}$ where $I$ is the set of fractional ideals and $P^+$ is the abelian group generated by all positive principals remaining positive under all real embedding.

Let $p,q$ be primes. Let $p,q^\star\equiv 1(\mod 4)$ where $q^\star=(-1)^{\frac{q-1}{2}}q$. Suppose $(\frac{q^\star}{p})=1$. Then $q^\star$ splits in $Q(\sqrt{p})$. Since $Q(\sqrt{p})$'s discriminant has only $p$ as prime divisor, $h(Q(\sqrt{p})$ is odd where $h(X)$ is the class number of number ring associated to the number field $X$. However $p=SS^\sigma$ where $S$ is the prime ideal lying above $p$ and $\sigma:\sqrt{p}\to-\sqrt{p}$.

$\textbf{Q:}$ Then the book says $S$ in narrow ideal class group is a square by class number odd. I do not see any particular obvious reason this has to be the case. Why is $\bar{S}\in C^+$ square? Probably one needs $(C^+)^2=(C^+)^{1-\sigma}$. I think I should consider $C_K\to C_K$ by $x\to x^2$ automorphism where $C_K$ is the class group. Since $h_O$ odd, kernel is trivial and this yields bijection by finiteness of $C_K$. Hence every $C_K$ representative is a square. Then $C^+\to C_K$ is surjection. Hence $S$ is a square in $C^+$. Is this correct?