Symmetric polynomials and the Newton identities

6.5k Views Asked by At

I want to write $P(x,y,z)=yx^{3}+zx^{3}+xy^{3}+zy^{3}+xz^{3}+yz^{3}$ in terms of elementary symmetric polynomials, but I'm getting stuck at the first step. I know I should follow the proof of the fundamental theorem of symmetric polynomials using the Newton identities.

First I pick out the 'biggest' monomial according to the lexicographical ordering: $yz^{3}$. Now I want to rewrite this as a polynomial in the elementary symmetric polynomials. I don't quite understand how to do this.

3

There are 3 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

By Gauss's algorithm below, if $\rm\ z^a\,y^b\, x^c\ $ is the highest w.r.t. lex order $\rm\ z > y > x\ $ then we subtract $\rm\ s_1^{a-b}\ s_2^{b-c}\ s_3^c\,$ to decrease its order. In our example $\rm\, z^3\, y\, $ is highest, therefore we subtract $\rm\ s_1^{3-1}\ s_2^{1-0}\ s_3^0 = (x+y+z)^2\ (xy+yz+zx)\,$ from $\rm\,P.\,$ The result is smaller in lex-order, hence iterating this reduction rewrites $\rm\:P\:$ as a polynomial in elementary symmetric polynomials $\rm\,s_i.\,$ Here the algorithm terminates in two more steps - see below. See here for another worked example.

As I mentioned in a prior post, Gauss's algorithm is the earliest known example of using lex-order reduction as in the Grobner basis algorithm. For a nice exposition see Chapter 7 of Cox, Little, O'Shea: Ideals, Varieties and Algorithms. They also give generalizations to the ring of invariants of a finite matrix group $\rm G \subset GL(n,k)$. Below is an excerpt which, coincidentally, presents this example. You might find it helpful to first read the example at the end before reading the proof.

alt text alt text

11
On

Edit: As per Bill's comment I would like to clarify that this is not related to Gauss' proof.

$$P(x,y,z)=yx^{3}+zx^{3}+xy^{3}+zy^{3}+xz^{3}+yz^{3}$$ $$=x^3(y+z+x-x)+y^3(x+z+y-y)+z^3(x+y+z-z)$$ $$=x^3(x+y+z)+y^3(x+y+z)+z^3(x+y+z)-x^4-y^4-z^4$$ $$=(x+y+z)(x^3+y^3+z^3)-(x^4+y^4+z^4)$$

Now you can use identities for power sums.

0
On

You stated:

I want to write $P(x,y,z)=yx^{3}+zx^{3}+xy^{3}+zy^{3}+xz^{3}+yz^{3}$ in terms of elementary symmetric polynomials,

The polynomial $P$ is homogeneous of degree $4$ and highest degree $3$. Therefore, using partitions of $4$ it can be written as a linear combination of the elementary symmetric functions $$e_1:=x+y+z,\; e_2:=xy+xz+yz,\; e_3:=xyz$$ of $x,y,z$ as $$ P(x,y,z) = S := a\,e_3e_1 +b\,e_2^2 +c\,e_2e_1^2 +d\,e_1^4. $$ Now $d=0$ since the highest degree of $P$ is $3$. Now, the expansion of $S$ has highest degree term of $x$ as $c\,x^3(y+z).$ Comparing this to $P$ implies $c=1.$ But now, the expansion of $S$ contains $(b+2)x^2z^2$ which implies $b=-2.$ Now the expansion of $S$ contains $(a+1)x^2yz$ which implies $a=-1.$ The final result is the equation $$ P(x,y,z) = -e_3e_1 -2\,e_2^2 +e_2e_1^2. $$