Trouble integrating a radical in the denominator for $ \int{x \over \sqrt{8-2x^2}}dx $

2.8k Views Asked by At

Currently trying to tackle MIT's 18.01 OCW 3rd problem set.

Problem 3A-2e: Compute the indefinite integral:

$$ \int{x \over \sqrt{8-2x^2}}dx $$

My solution

Restate the problem as $\int x(8-2x^2)^{-1/2}dx$.

Via substitution or what they call advanced guessing, arrive at a solution of $${-1 \over 2}(8-2x^2)^{1/2} + c$$

OCW's Solution

Guess $(8-2x^2)^{3/2}$ for the non-constant term. Looks good, but it needs a coefficient to get it in the final form: $${-1 \over 6}(8-2x^2)^{3/2} + c$$

My confusion

It appears that if the OCW had restated the problem, it would have done so as $(8-2x^2)^{1/2}$, which is to say that they seem to have addressed only the denominator of the total function. I cannot figure out what happens to the $x$ numerator, nor the status of the radical term as the denominator of a fraction.

I am at such a loss, I began to suspect a typo, but I thought the best thing would be to ask others. The OCW forum is just about useless. Thanks in advance, folks.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

You can see that your solution is correct by taking the derivative. The other answer gives the indefinite integral of $x\sqrt{8-2x^2}$. You can see this by taking the derivative of $-\frac16 (8-2x^2)^{3/2}$.

The solution you have now linked to has several errors. First was misreading the problem, or somehow turning $\dfrac{1}{\sqrt u}$ into $u^{1/2}$. Then in the second method, the derivative of $-2x^2$ was incorrectly given as $-4x^2$, then at the next step $x^2$ disappeared to get a result that matches neither the original integrand nor their mistaken integrand.