Two different recurrent relations for the same index using frobenius' method

218 Views Asked by At

I'm trying to solve the following differential equation using Frobenius' method: 4xy''+2y''+y=0

I checked x=0 is a regular singular point and performed the substitution $y=x^{\lambda}\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}a_{n}x^n$

Then after multiplying everything through I got two series, one multiplying with x^n-1 and the other with x^n, if I shift the index of the latter n->n-1 and take the term corresponding to n=0 out of the first one I can put everything inside a sum that starts at n=1 and multiplies with x^n-1:

$\frac{a_{0}}{x}(4\lambda(\lambda -1)+2\lambda )) + \sum_{n=1}^{\infty }(a_{n}(4(n+\lambda)(n+\lambda-1)+(2n+2\lambda))+a_{n-1})x^{n-1}=0$

from the indicial equation I find indices 1/2 and 0. Then, using the first index, I get the recurrence relation $a_{n}=\frac{-a_{n-1}}{2n(2n+1)}$ which I believe is correct and gives me one of the solutions y1=Acos(x^(1/2))

However, if I had instead put everything inside a sum times x^n, by taking the n=0 term of the series out and then shifting the index with n->n+1 I get the following

$\frac{a_{0}}{x}(4\lambda(\lambda -1)+2\lambda )) + \sum_{n=0}^{\infty }(a_{n+1}(4(n+\lambda+1)(n+\lambda)+2(n+\lambda+1))+a_{n})x^{n}=0$

which when making each coefficient of x vanish gives me a different relation $a_{n+1}=\frac{-a_{n}}{4n^2+10n+6}$

I know I must be doing something wrong since they should both give me the same answer but shouldn't the two series be equivalent and give the same recurrence relations?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

using the first index, I get the recurrence relation $a_{n}=\frac{-a_{n-1}}{2n(2n+1)}$
$\cdots$
However [...] gives me a different relation $a_{n+1}=\frac{-a_{n}}{4n^2+10n+6}$

The relations are in fact one and the same, only written for different indices. If you take the first one and replace $\,n \mapsto \color{blue}{n+1}\,$ you get precisely the second one:

$$\require{cancel} a_{\color{blue}{n+1}}=\frac{-a_{\color{blue}{n+\bcancel{1}}-\bcancel{1}}}{2(\color{blue}{n+1})\big(2(\color{blue}{n+1})+1\big)} = \frac{-a_n}{(2n+2)(2n+3)} = \frac{-a_n}{4n^2+10n+6} $$