Understanding the solution to this polynomial estimation problem

45 Views Asked by At

Show that there exist $K, N > 0$ such that for $x ∈\mathbb{R}$, $$x ≥ N \implies \frac{3x^ 2 − 4x + 8}{ 5x + 6} ≥ Kx.$$

Solution:

For $x ≥ 4,$ we have $4x ≤ x^ 2$ so that $$3x^ 2 − 4x + 8 ≥ 3x^ 2 − x^ 2 = 2x^ 2.$$

Similarly, for $x ≥ 1,$ we have $$5x + 6 ≤ 11x.$$ Therefore, when $x ≥ 4,$ we have $$\frac{3x^ 2 − 4x + 8}{ 5x + 6} ≥\frac{ 2x^ 2}{ 11x} = \frac{2} {11} x,$$

and so we can take $N = 4$ and $K = \frac{2}{ 11} .$

I'm struggling to follow the logical steps in this solution. I'm not sure why the inequality of $x ≥ 4$ and $x ≥ 1$ has been chosen. Can someone please break down this solution and show where the steps come from?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Essentially the method of attack that was used in this proof is to find a quadratic function that is less than the numerator and a linear function that is greater than the denominator. Then when you divide these you get a linear function which is less than the original $\frac{3x^2-4x+8}{5x+6}$.

In layman's terms the question is asking if it is possible to find some real number $N$ such that $\frac{3x^2-4x+8}{5x+6}$ is greater than some linear function $Kx$ for all $x$ greater than or equal to $N$.

So again we are looking for a quadratic equation which is less than $3x^2-4x+8$ for some values of $x > 0$. Notice that $3x^2 + 8 \geq 3x^2 $ for all $x > 0$. Now we need to account for the $-4x$ term still in the numerator. There's actually an infinite amount of choices we could do for the next step. In the proof you presented the author realized that $x^2$ would be greater than or equal to $4x$ eventually (namely at $x = 4$). So from the inequality above we note that $3x^2 - 4x + 8 \geq 3x^2 - x^2 = 2x^2$ when $x \geq 4$ (because we subtracted something greater from the RHS than the LHS).

Now for the next step again we have an infinite amount of choices, however the author realized that $5x +6 \leq 11x$ when $x \geq 1$. Of course they could just have easily said $5x+6 \leq 12x$ or an infinite number of other choices for that matter (thus finding a different value of $K$) but they chose this. Now since $5x + 6 \leq 11x$ when $x \geq 1, $ it is certainly also true when $x \geq4.$

Now for the final step, we can obtain the equation $\frac{3x^2 - 4x + 8}{5x+6} \geq \frac{2x^2}{11x} = \frac{2}{11}x$ for $x \geq 4$ because the numerator of the LHS is greater than the numerator of the RHS and the denominator of the LHS is less than the numerator of the RHS for $x\geq4$ as we showed above.

Thus we can pick $N = 4$ and $K = \frac{2}{11}$. To make sure you understand it try and find another value of $N$ and $K$, for instance by realizing that $3x^2 - 4x + 8 \geq 3x^2 -2x^2 = x^2$ for $x \geq 4$ in the first step.