What do these contour maps tell me about my Collatz expression?

140 Views Asked by At

I tested this limit on WolframAlpha, $$ \lim_{t\to\infty}\frac {2\ 3^r (2 t - 1) - 6} {3\ 2^r (2 t - 1) - 6}=\left(\frac{3}{2}\right)^{r-1},$$

which displayed two contour maps:

enter image description here enter image description here.

Can someone describe the what we are seeing? Anything notable?

Edit Question has been answered, but I've added motivaton. In Mathematica, when we take the limit to a specific triangle $t$, we get a generating function for that triangle that produces all numbers that need to be proved to always be fractions, in order to prove there are no loop-backs in Collatz. Say we set $t\rightarrow2$, we get $\frac{2 \left(3^r-1\right)}{3\ 2^r-2}$, then we get $\{\frac{8}{5},\frac{26}{11},\frac{80}{23},\frac{242}{47},\frac{728}{95},\frac{2186}{191},\frac{6560}{383},\frac{1514}{59},\frac{59048}{1535}\}$ for the first few $r$'s. If we can prove this for all triangles, we can show that no looping occurs in Collatz.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

This limit is rather simple, being of the form $lim_{t\to \infty}(at+b)/(ct+d)=a/c$. The fact that $r$ and $t$ be integer and $t$ a multiple of $r$ has no impact, there is still an accumulation point at $\infty$.

The plot is of little use, but the 3D view clearly shows the exponential behavior as a function of $r$, just perturbed by the zeroes of the denominator. These appear as an exponential curve on the 2D diagram but are irrelevant for the limit computation.