What is the point of vectors who's components add to zero?

2.2k Views Asked by At

I am doing a simple practice question:

Every combination of v = (1,-2,1) and w = (0,1,-1) has components that add to ____ . Find c and d so that cv + dw = (3,3,-6). Why is (3,3,6) impossible?

I know the blank is "zero" and c = 3, d = 9. The last part I didn't get --- (3,3,6) is impossible because it doesn't add up to zero.

What am I supposed to take away from this? Is there some property or definition here? (I'm starting linear algebra)

3

There are 3 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

You have two linearly independent vectors $(1,-2,1)$ and $(0,1,-1)$ in the three dimensional space $\mathbb {R^3}$

Any linear combination of $(1,-2,1)$ and $(0,1,-1)$ is a vector whose components add up to $0$

The subspace spanned by these two vectors is a two dimensional subspace which does not include vectors whose components do not add up to $0$.

Therefore $(3,3,6)$ is not in that subspace since it is not a linear combination of $(1,-2,1)$ and $(0,1,-1)$

1
On

I would think of the problem this way: suppose you can move around $\mathbb{R}^3$ along the directions of the two vectors ${\bf v}=(1,-2,1)$ and ${\bf w}=(0,1,-1)$ (and let's say you start from the origin). Now, where can you go?

The point is that you can get from the origin to a point in this way if that point (or rather, the position vector of that point: the vector from the origin to the point) can be written in the form $c{\bf v}+d{\bf w}$ for some scalars $c$ and $d$ ("move $c$ units in the ${\bf v}$-direction and $d$ units in the ${\bf w}$-direction and you'll be there"). So this exercise is showing that you can get to $(3,3,-6)$ but you can't get to $(3,3,6)$.

Why this is a valuable question to ask, you'll learn later; for now, you're just exploring the way vectors let you move around the space (or, if you prefer, how vectors describe regions in the space) via linear combinations.

0
On

The takeaway of this question is:

when the sum of components of v is 0, the sum of components of w is 0, then every combination of v and w has components that sum is zero.