Why does two joined circles (wedge sum) with a point removed deformation retract to a single circle?

690 Views Asked by At

Let $X$ and $Y$ be two unit circles in $\mathbb{R}^2$. $X$ is centered at $(1,0)$, while $Y$ is centered at $(-1,0)$.

Consider $A = X \cup Y$. Let $p \in Y$ be a point that is not $(0,0)$.

Why is $X$ a deformation retract of $A - p$?

Attempt: Intuitively, I can expand the hole in $Y$ and pushed both "arms" into the point $(0,0)$. But what would the retract $r: A - p \to X$ be exactly?

Also, the fact that $Y - p$ is homeomorphic to the real line via sterographic projection, and that the real line is contractible feels like I should be able to retract $Y-p$ to the point $(0,0)$.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Let $p = (-1 + \cos\psi, \sin\psi)$ for $\psi \in (-\pi, \pi)$. Consider $H: A\setminus\{p\} \times [0, 1] \to A\setminus\{p\}$ given by

$$H((-1+\cos\theta, \sin\theta), t) = \begin{cases} (-1 + \cos((1-t)\psi-t\pi), \sin((1-t)\psi-t\pi)) & \theta \in (-\pi, \psi)\\ (-1 + \cos((1-t)\psi+t\pi), \sin((1-t)\psi+t\pi)) & \theta \in (\psi, \pi) \end{cases}$$

and $H(x, t) = x$ otherwise. The first case retracts the bottom arc to $(0, 0)$ while the second case retracts the top arc to $(0, 0)$.