Why is $\mathcal{D}'$, the space of distributions, closed under addition, scalar multiplication, and multiplication?

35 Views Asked by At

For context:

  • $\Omega$ is an open subset of $\mathbb{R}^n$.
  • $\mathcal{D}(\Omega)$ is the space of test (smooth, compactly supported) functions $\Omega\to\mathbb{C}$ with a complete, unmetrizable topology $\tau$.
  • $\mathcal{D}_K(\Omega)$ is the space of test functions supported on the compact set $K\subseteq \Omega$, with a Fréchet-space topology $\tau_K$ that corresponds with the subspace topology under $\tau$.
  • $\mathcal{D}'(\Omega)$ is the space of distributions i.e. of continuous linear functionals $\mathcal{D}(\Omega)\to\mathbb{C}$.

All the above is as explained in chapter 1 and 6 of Rudin's Functional Analysis.

I had the following written in my personal notes: $\def\L{\Lambda} \def\DDD{\mathcal{D}} \def\W{\Omega} \def\CC{\mathbb{C}}$

Result: let $\L_1,\L_2\in\DDD'(\W)$, and $z\in\CC$, then

  1. $\L_1+\L_2\in\DDD'(\W)$.
  2. $z\L_1\in\DDD'(\W)$.
  3. $\L_1\cdot \L_2\in\DDD'(\W)$.

As for the proof, I merely wrote that it follows from elementary results on continuity of maps between topological vector spaces, but I could not find any result that would easily imply the result above, so I set out to prove it directly:

Fix a compact $K\subseteq \W$, and suppose $$|\L_1(\phi)| \le C_1\|\phi\|_N \ \ \ \ \text{ and } \ \ \ \ |\L_2(\phi)| \le C_2\|\phi\|_M$$ for all $\phi\in\DDD_K(\W)$. For addition, we have

$$|(\L_1+\L_2)\phi| = |\L_1(\phi)+\L_2(\phi)|\le |\L_1(\phi)|+|\L_2(\phi)| \le C_1\|\phi\|_N + C_2\|\phi\|_M \le (C_1+C_2)\|\phi\|_{\max(N,M)}.$$

For scalar multiplication, we note $$|z\L_1(\phi)| \le |z|C_1\|\phi\|_N.$$

Finally, for multiplication, we have $$|(\L_1\cdot\L_2)(\phi)| = |\L_1(\phi)\L_2(\phi)| \le C_1\|\phi\|_NC_2\|\phi\|_M \le \ldots$$


Questions:

  • Is the proof for addition and scalar multiplication valid?

  • How could one finish the proof for multiplication?