Will gravity pull the tool back or is it lost forever?

114 Views Asked by At

Consider aspacecraft with mass $M=160\:\rm Mg$. An astronaut on the craft, in trying to stop the thruster, lost a tool with mass $m=250\:\rm g$. The tool now sits $2\:\rm m$ from (outer shell of) the spacecraft.

A question asks: If the tool is travelling with a speed of $2\:\rm m/s$ will gravity pull the tool back or is it lost forever?

Is it alright just to find the the escape velocity and compare it to the speed of the tool? The questions is worth a lot so I am confused.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

This should moved to Physics.SE, but I'm writing this to provide an answer for there after move completion.

Yes, what you want is the escape velocity from the spacecraft. However, finding that is actually quite tricky in this case: the spacecraft is an extended object! The usual formula for escape velocity,

$$v_\mathrm{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{r}}$$

is based on the assumption that the object is either point-like or spherically symmetric. A real spacecraft is likely neither, and even in this case you can't necessarily assume a "spherical cow" because the radial distance $r$ in the case of an extended spherically-symmetric object must be measured from the center, not the surface, and you are given the distance from the spacecraft surface.

That said, the escape velocity for an extended mass distribution at a distance from its surface will, generally speaking, be lower than that same distance from it concentrated at a point, so you can use this as an upper bound on the escape speed.

Thus, given that in this system of units $G \approx 6.6743\ \times 10^{-8}\ \mathrm{\frac{kN \cdot m^2}{Mg^2}}$, then taking $M = 160\ \mathrm{Mg}$ and $r = 2\ \mathrm{m}$ gives the upper bound on $v_\mathrm{esc}$ as about 0.0033 m/s. Hence, yes, the screwdriver escapes easily.

(And this is all the more guaranteed by the fact that it is apparently thrusting away, which will cause it to leave in a hurry!)