A line connecting an interior and an exterior point of a circle should intersect the circle at some point

362 Views Asked by At

How can someone prove in Euclidean geometry that the statement

"A line connecting an interior and an exterior point of a circle should intersect the circle at some point"

follows from the axioms of Hilbert or Birkhoff? I cannot find any relevant information inside Hilbert's book or Birkhoff's paper.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

10
On

From the definitions you gave in the comments,

Everything is on the same plane. An interior point of a circle with center $O$ and radius $r$ is a point $A$ such that $|OA|<r$. A point $A$ is exterior of that circle if $|OA|>r$.

it is fairly straight forward to see that, if we choose point $A$ such that $|OA|<r$ (inside the circle) and point B such that $|OB|>r$ (outside the circle) then at some point on the line that joins $A$ and $B$ we must have a point $C$ such that $|OC|=r$ and thus the point is on the circle.


Consider this diagram

circle

It is obvious that $|OA|<r$ and $|OB|>r$, matching our definitions.

We draw the purple line $AB$. We can immediately see that this crosses the circle line, now it just remains to prove this fact.

If we plot a graph of $|OP|$ for all points $P$ on $AB$ then we will get something of the following shape.

graph

We can use the Intermediate Value Theorem to say that there must be a point between $A$ and $B$ where $|OP|=r$ and we call this point $C$ and say that it must lie on the circle.