A math puzzle about slow clock

5.1k Views Asked by At

You have the misfortune to own an unreliable clock. This one loses exactly 20 minutes every hour. It is now showing 4:00am and you know that is was correct at midnight, when you set it. The clock stopped 4 hours ago, what is the correct time now?

OK.. I did really solve it. However, my solution was simple: to literally write the time while an hour is 40min opposite to time when an hour is just an hour, 60 mins:

12:40 - 1 AM
1:20 - 2
2:00 - 3
2:40 - 4
3:20 - 5
4:00 AM- 6:00AM

and then add 4 hours so the answer is 10:00 AM.

Now another solution goes like this:

Since the clock is losing 20 minutes every hour, for every real hour that has passed, the clock will only show 40 minutes. Since the clock shows 4:00am, we know that 240 clock minutes have passed. This therefore equals 360 real minutes and hence 6 hours. The clock stopped 4 hour ago and the time must now be 10:00am.

Assumably, you could do 240:40 = 6 and there you go.. 6 additional hours to 12 AM.

What I don't understand is why divide 240 by 40? 240 mins reflect the "real" time when an hour is 60 minutes, why divide it by "40 minutes hour"?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

The quantity "$240$ minutes" describes the amount of time shown on the clock. Since we know the clock is inaccurate, these "$240$ minutes" do not reflect "real" time. They reflect "clock" time.

$40$ minutes of "clock" time elapse in one hour of real time. So $40n$ minutes of "clock" time is $n$ hours of real time. Letting $240 = 40n$, we want to solve for $n$. What is the first step in solving that equation?


An alternative approach is: since the clock records only $\frac23$ hour for each hour of real time that passes, it takes $\frac32$ hour of real time for the clock to advance one hour. For the clock to advance $m$ hours takes $\frac32 m$ real hours. Since the clock advanced four hours, set $m = 4.$ But as noted in a comment, this is really doing the same thing, just in a slightly different order of computation and using different units.