A minimal normal group of a solvable group is abelian

277 Views Asked by At

Definition: We say that $H$ is a minimal normal group of $G$ if $H\lhd{G}$ and $\forall K\lneq{H}$ , $K\neq{\{e}\}$ it holds that $ K\ntriangleleft{G}$.

Let $G$ be a finite solvable group, and let $H$ be a minimal normal group of $G$. Prove that $H$ is abelian.

I wrote a solution but it feels too easy and it proves a stronger claim- that $Z(G)=H$ , so I think it might be wrong:

Since every $g\in{Z(G)}$ commutes with every $h\in{H}$ , it holds that $Z(G)\leq{Z(H)}\leq{H}$. Since $Z(G)\lhd{G}$ , and $H$ is a minimal normal group of $G$, we get that $Z(G)=H$ or $Z(G)={\{e}\}$ . But $G$ is solvable, so we get $Z(G)\neq{\{e}\}$ and therefore $Z(G)=H$ and $H$ is abelian.

I'd like to know if this proof is correct, and if it's wrong, some guidence would be much appreciated.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

Your argument commits several errors.

For one thing, solvable groups may have trivial centers (for example, $S_3$).

For another, It is false that $Z(G)\leq Z(H)$ for $H\leq G$. What is true is that $Z(G)\cap H\leq Z(H)$, but again, in general, there is absolutely no reason to assume that a central element of $G$ must be in $H$, and so there is no reason to think it will lie in the center of $H$. When you argue that elements of $Z(G)$ commute with every element of $H$, the conclusion is not that $Z(G)\leq Z(H)$, but rather that $Z(G)\leq C_G(H)$, the centralizer of $H$. The centralizer also contains $Z(H)$, but that doesn’t tell you anything about whether $Z(G)$ and $Z(H)$ have any containment relationship with each other.

As for an argument, here are few things you may want to prove:

  1. Subgroups of solvable groups are solvable.

  2. If $K$ is solvable, then $[K,K]\neq K$.

  3. If $N\triangleleft G$, then $[N,N]\triangleleft G$.

Use those facts to show the desired result.