Algebra transitive action (Isaacs 4.1)

166 Views Asked by At

I'm working on the following questions and I'm unable to make any progress on it. Can anyone offer any insight?

Let $G$ act transitively on a set $\Omega$ and suppose $G$ is finite. Define an action of $G$ on $\Omega \times \Omega$ by putting $(\alpha, \beta) \cdot g =(\alpha\cdot g, \beta\cdot g)$. Let $\alpha \in \Omega$. Show that $G$ has the same number of orbits on $\Omega \times \Omega$ as $G_{\alpha}$ does on $\Omega$.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On

There is a map from $G_{\alpha}$ orbits on $\Omega$ to $G$ orbits on $\Omega \times \Omega$. Take an orbit $G_{\alpha}\beta$ and send it to the $G$ orbit of $(\alpha, \beta)$. If $\beta'$ is another representative of this orbit, $g \beta = \beta'$ with $g \in G_{\alpha}$, then $(\alpha, \beta')$ and $(\alpha, \beta)$ are in the same orbit since $g(\alpha, \beta) = (\alpha, \beta')$. So this map is well defined.

Now, show it is injective and surjective.

0
On

With character theory this can be proved rather easily. Put $\chi(g)=\#\{\alpha \in \Omega: \alpha^ g=\alpha\}$. Then the function $\chi$ is called the permutation character of the action of $G$ on $\Omega$. It is a standard fact (basically the Burnside-Cauchy-Frobenius Lemma) that the number of orbits of $\Omega$ under the action of $G$ equals $[\chi,1_G]$. Write $G_{\alpha}$ for the subgroup of $G$ fixing $\alpha$. You need the following.

Lemma Let $G$ act transitively on $\Omega$. Then the number of orbits of $G_{\alpha}$ acting on $\Omega$ equals $[\chi,\chi]$.
For a proof see I.M. Isaacs, Character Theory of Finite Groups, (5.16).

Now the key observation is that the permutation character of $G$ acting on $\Omega \times \Omega$ is exactly the character $\chi^2$, since if $g \in G$ has $\chi(g)$ fixed points on $\Omega$, it has $\chi(g)^2$ fixed points on $\Omega \times \Omega$ – namely one for every pair of fixed points in the action on $\Omega$. Therefore $[\chi^2,1_G]$ is the number of orbits in the action of $G$ on $\Omega \times \Omega$. But obviously $[\chi^2,1_G]=[\chi,\chi]$ and by the Lemma we are done.