An add-on question on Rolle's theorem

108 Views Asked by At

I must demonstrate that there exists $c \in (a,b)$ where $a,b \ne 0$ such that $f'(c)=c\!\cdot\!f(c)$ if the Rolle's theorem's third condition, which is $f(a)=f(b)$, is replaced by $\dfrac{f(a)}{a}=\dfrac {f(b)}{b}$. Please suggest how I should proceed.

EDIT: Attaching the snap of the question. (The answer is option c) EDIT1: The answer key must be incorrect. The obvious answer should be option d) as evident from the counter examples in the answers and comments below. enter image description here

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

If $\;0<a<b\;$ or $\;a<b<0\;$, we can take into consideration the following function:

$g:[a,b]\to\Bbb R\;$ defined as

$g(x)=\dfrac{f(x)}x\;\;$ for any $\;x\in[a,b]\,.$

The function $\;g(x)\;$ satisfies all the hypothesis of Rolle's theorem, hence there exists $\;\xi\in(a,b)\;$ such that $\;g’(\xi)=0\,.$

Since $\;g’(\xi)=\dfrac{\xi f’(\xi)-f(\xi)}{\xi^2}\;,\;$ it follows that

$\xi f’(\xi)=f(\xi)\,.$

It means that actually the correct answer is the option (D).



Addendum :

If $\;a<0<b\;,\;$ there are functions $\;f:[a,b]\to\Bbb R\;$ continuous on $\,[a,b]\,,\,$ differentiable on $\,(a,b)\,$ such that $\,\dfrac{f(a)}a=\dfrac{f(b)}b\,,\,$ but the option (C) is not satisfied.

For example :

$f:[-1,1]\to\Bbb R\;$ defined as

$f(x)=x^2+x-1\;\;$ for any $\;x\in[-1,1]\,.$

This function $\,f(x)\,$ is continuous on $\,[-1,1]\,,\,$ differentiable on $\,(-1,1)\,,\;$ moreover

$\dfrac{f(-1)}{-1}=\dfrac{f(1)}1\;,\;\;$ but

$xf’(x)=2x^2+x>f(x)\;\;$ for any $\;x\in(-1,1)\,.$

Consequently, there does not exist any $\;\xi\in(-1,1)\;$ such that $\;\xi f’(\xi)=f(\xi)\,.$



Another addendum :

The option (C) cannot be correct, indeed there exists the following counterexample:

$f:[2,3]\to\Bbb R\;\;$ defined as $\;f(x)=x\;$ for any $\,x\in[2,3]\,.$

This function $\,f(x)\,$ is continuous on $\,[2,3]\,,\,$ differentiable on $\,(2,3)\,,\,$ moreover

$\dfrac{f(2)}2=\dfrac{f(3)}3\;\;$ but

$\dfrac{f’(x)}{f(x)}=\dfrac1x<\dfrac12<2<x\;\;$ for any $\,x\in(2,3)\,.$

Consequently, there does not exist any $\;\xi\in(2,3)\;$ such that

$\dfrac{f’(\xi)}{f(\xi)}=\xi\,.$

3
On

We have to consider $f(a)=0=f(b)$, additionally

Consider $g(x)=e^{-x^2/2}f(x)$ such that $g(a)=0=g(b)$. Apply Rolle's theorem on $g(x)$, so $g'(x)=-x e^{-x^2/2} f(x)+e^{-x^2/2} f'(x)=0$ for $x =c, c\in (a,b) \implies f'(c)=cf(c), c\in (a,b)$.