Assuming the axiom of choice , how to prove that every uncountable abelian group must have an uncountable proper subgroup ? Related to Does there exist any uncountable group , every proper subgroup of which is countable? , Asaf Karagila answered it there in a comment , but in a contrapositive way , I am looking for a direct proof of this claim assuming choice . Thanks in advance
2026-03-26 22:18:10.1774563490
Assuming the axiom of choice ,how to prove that every uncountable abelian group must have an uncountable proper subgroup?
451 Views Asked by user228168 https://math.techqa.club/user/user228168/detail At
1
There are 1 best solutions below
Related Questions in GROUP-THEORY
- What is the intersection of the vertices of a face of a simplicial complex?
- Group with order $pq$ has subgroups of order $p$ and $q$
- How to construct a group whose "size" grows between polynomially and exponentially.
- Conjugacy class formula
- $G$ abelian when $Z(G)$ is a proper subset of $G$?
- A group of order 189 is not simple
- Minimal dimension needed for linearization of group action
- For a $G$ a finite subgroup of $\mathbb{GL}_2(\mathbb{R})$ of rank $3$, show that $f^2 = \textrm{Id}$ for all $f \in G$
- subgroups that contain a normal subgroup is also normal
- Could anyone give an **example** that a problem that can be solved by creating a new group?
Related Questions in ELEMENTARY-SET-THEORY
- how is my proof on equinumerous sets
- Composition of functions - properties
- Existence of a denumerble partition.
- Why is surjectivity defined using $\exists$ rather than $\exists !$
- Show that $\omega^2+1$ is a prime number.
- A Convention of Set Builder Notation
- I cannot understand that $\mathfrak{O} := \{\{\}, \{1\}, \{1, 2\}, \{3\}, \{1, 3\}, \{1, 2, 3\}\}$ is a topology on the set $\{1, 2, 3\}$.
- Problem with Cartesian product and dimension for beginners
- Proof that a pair is injective and surjective
- Value of infinite product
Related Questions in ABELIAN-GROUPS
- How to construct a group whose "size" grows between polynomially and exponentially.
- $G$ abelian when $Z(G)$ is a proper subset of $G$?
- Invariant factor decomposition of quotient group of two subgroups of $\mathbb{Z}^n$.
- Computing Pontryagin Duals
- Determine the rank and the elementary divisors of each of the following groups.
- existence of subgroups of finite abelian groups
- Theorem of structure for abelian groups
- In the category of abelian groups the coequalizer $\text{Coker}(f, 0)$, $f: A \to B$ is simply $B/f(A)$.
- Commutator subgroup and simple groups
- Are there any interesting examples of functions on Abelian groups that are not homomorphisms?
Related Questions in AXIOM-OF-CHOICE
- Do I need the axiom of choice to prove this statement?
- Canonical choice of many elements not contained in a set
- Strength of $\sf ZF$+The weak topology on every Banach space is Hausdorff
- Example of sets that are not measurable?
- A,B Sets injective map A into B or bijection subset A onto B
- Equivalence of axiom of choice
- Proving the axiom of choice in propositions as types
- Does Diaconescu's theorem imply cubical type theory is non-constructive?
- How does Axiom of Choice imply Axiom of Dependent Choice?
- How does Axiom of Dependent Choice imply this weaker variant?
Related Questions in INFINITE-GROUPS
- Subgroup of index p in an infinite p-group?
- For general $n \in \Bbb N$ , how to determine all groups (both finite and infinite) having exactly $n$ conjugacy classes?
- Geometrical interpretation of a group
- Is there a good example of a subgroup of an infinitely generated abelian group that is not isomorphic to a quotient of that group?
- An infinite polycyclic group has a free abelian normal subgroup
- Orbits of $X$ under $N\triangleleft G$ are of equal length
- Infinite case: Let $N$ be a normal subgroup of index m in $G$. Prove that $a^{m}\in N$ for all $a\in G$
- Show that the infinite cyclic group is not isomorphic to a direct product of two nontrivial cyclic groups.
- If an infinite group acts freely on two sets then the sets are bijective via an action preserving bijection?
- If an infinite group $G$ acts freely on two sets of same cardinality $> |G|$, then the sets are bijective via an action preserving bijection?
Trending Questions
- Induction on the number of equations
- How to convince a math teacher of this simple and obvious fact?
- Find $E[XY|Y+Z=1 ]$
- Refuting the Anti-Cantor Cranks
- What are imaginary numbers?
- Determine the adjoint of $\tilde Q(x)$ for $\tilde Q(x)u:=(Qu)(x)$ where $Q:U→L^2(Ω,ℝ^d$ is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator and $U$ is a Hilbert space
- Why does this innovative method of subtraction from a third grader always work?
- How do we know that the number $1$ is not equal to the number $-1$?
- What are the Implications of having VΩ as a model for a theory?
- Defining a Galois Field based on primitive element versus polynomial?
- Can't find the relationship between two columns of numbers. Please Help
- Is computer science a branch of mathematics?
- Is there a bijection of $\mathbb{R}^n$ with itself such that the forward map is connected but the inverse is not?
- Identification of a quadrilateral as a trapezoid, rectangle, or square
- Generator of inertia group in function field extension
Popular # Hahtags
second-order-logic
numerical-methods
puzzle
logic
probability
number-theory
winding-number
real-analysis
integration
calculus
complex-analysis
sequences-and-series
proof-writing
set-theory
functions
homotopy-theory
elementary-number-theory
ordinary-differential-equations
circles
derivatives
game-theory
definite-integrals
elementary-set-theory
limits
multivariable-calculus
geometry
algebraic-number-theory
proof-verification
partial-derivative
algebra-precalculus
Popular Questions
- What is the integral of 1/x?
- How many squares actually ARE in this picture? Is this a trick question with no right answer?
- Is a matrix multiplied with its transpose something special?
- What is the difference between independent and mutually exclusive events?
- Visually stunning math concepts which are easy to explain
- taylor series of $\ln(1+x)$?
- How to tell if a set of vectors spans a space?
- Calculus question taking derivative to find horizontal tangent line
- How to determine if a function is one-to-one?
- Determine if vectors are linearly independent
- What does it mean to have a determinant equal to zero?
- Is this Batman equation for real?
- How to find perpendicular vector to another vector?
- How to find mean and median from histogram
- How many sides does a circle have?
Yes. Assuming the axiom of choice the answer is positive. You can find the proof in W.R. Scott's paper:
The axiom of choice is used there for all manner of cardinal arithmetics.
Without the axiom of choice it is no longer necessary that the proof can go through. Because it is consistent that there is a vector space over $\Bbb Q$ which is not finitely generated, but every proper subspace is in fact finitely generated.
Of course this means that the vector space is not countable, since otherwise the usual arguments would show it has a countable basis, and therefore it has an infinitely dimensional proper subspace.
The result is originally due to Lauchli, and in my masters thesis I refurbished the argument and showed that you can also require "countably generated" instead "finitely generated".