Axiomatic system vs Formal System

1.1k Views Asked by At

What's the differences beetween Axiomatic systems and Formal Systems ? What i think is that an Axiomatic system is simply a less strict version of a Formal System, as the answer to this question says.

And, for example, linear algebra stands on an axiomatic system, instead First Order Logic stands on a formal system.Is it true ?

What do you think ?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

Terminology is fluid (as Carl Mummert remarks). But in many/most people's hands, axiomatic vs non-axiomatic and informal vs formal mark orthogonal distinctions.

You can have informal and formal axiomatic systems (Euclid vs first order Peano Arithmetic). You can axiomatic vs non-axiomatic systems, whether fully formal or otherwise (e.g. axiomatic and natural deduction systems of first order logic).

Axiomatization is a matter of how some theoretical apparatus is organised: do we lay down some "starter" propositions, and then some rules for deriving more propositions? Or do we, e.g. regiment just using derivation rules?

Formalization is a matter of how stringent we are in specifying that apparatus -- usual informal mathematical standards of rigour or the sort of specifications we could (in principle) feed to a computer for formal checking?