Basic example in diagram chasing

89 Views Asked by At

Consider the following diagram:

enter image description here

Given that $h \circ f = k$ and $l \circ h = g$, prove that $ g \circ f = l \circ k $

Answer: enter image description here page-35, An introduction to Category Theory, Harold Simmons

I am a bit confused, doesn't the first diagram itself have the proof? It is pretty clear that moving by $k$ then by $l$ gives same thing as moving by $f$ and $g$ to me. So, what more of an idea is put in the step wise proof?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

I think you are being falsely reassured by the picture of the diagram, which makes things seem like they are obvious. But imagine you are given a group $G$, and elements $f,g,h,k,l\in G$ such that $h\cdot f=k$ and $l\cdot h =g$. Now you want to prove that $g\cdot f = l\cdot k$. Of course, it's easy: $$g\cdot f=(l\cdot h)\cdot f = l\cdot (h\cdot f) = l\cdot k,$$ but it's clear that it requires this computation to give the proof. You would not get away with saying "it's just clear".

The visual dimension of diagrams is extremely useful, but you should not forget that in the end it's just a shortcut for a lot of formal equations, and that any "visual reasoning" is justified by computations. The computation you're looking at is basically saying that in a diagram, as long as all triangles commute, then everything commutes.