Bombelli's solution to a cubic

168 Views Asked by At

On p151 of my edition of Ian Stewart's "The Problems of Mathematics", he describes early work with imaginaries and Cardano's noting that Tartaglia's formula for solving a cubic, when applied to:

$$ x^3=15x+4 \tag{1}$$

yields

$$ x=\sqrt[3]{2}+\sqrt{-121}+ \sqrt[3]{2} - \sqrt{-121} \tag{2}$$

Bombelli, he then notes showed that:

$$ (2 \pm \sqrt{-1})^3 = 2 \pm \sqrt{-121} \tag{3}$$

Allowing us to restate (2) as:

$$ x=(2 + \sqrt{-1}) + (2 - \sqrt{-1}) = 4 \tag{4}$$

What I cannot follow is the substitution from (3) into (2) that gives us (4). Could someone explain?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Equation 2 should read $$x = \sqrt[3]{2 + \sqrt{-121}} + \sqrt[3]{2 - \sqrt{-121}}$$ which resolves the issue.