Bounding $x_{0}$ in solutions to Diophantine equation $\left(\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i}\right)^{2} = x_{0}\prod_{i=1}^{n}x_{i}$

133 Views Asked by At

Based on some computational experiments, it seems that, if $x_{0}, x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n} \in \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 1}$ are such that \begin{equation*} \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i}\right)^{2} = x_{0}\prod_{i=1}^{n}x_{i}, \end{equation*} then $x_{0} \le n^{2}$.

Is this bound known to be true? And (to ask a less precise question) whether or not this bound is true, where should one get started to learn methods for proving bounds like this, assuming no background beyond elementary number theory?

3

There are 3 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

Here is a solution. Thank you to Will Jagy for suggesting Vieta jumping. I had been trying Vieta jumping, but I guess I needed a bit more encouragement to push it through.

Let $x_{0} \in \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 1}$ be such that \begin{equation} \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i}\right)^{2} = x_{0}\prod_{i=1}^{n}x_{i} \label{eq:1} \end{equation} for some positive integers $x_{1} \le \dotsb \le x_{n}$. Using Vieta jumping, we may assume, without loss of generality, that $x_{1} \le \dotsb \le x_{n} \le \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} x_{i}$. For, Equation \ref{eq:1} is equivalent to \begin{equation*} x_{n}^{2} - \left(\prod_{i=0}^{n-1}x_{i} - 2 \sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}\right) x_{n} + \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}\right)^{2} = 0. \end{equation*} Letting $x_{n}'$ be the other root of the polynomial $t^{2} - \left(\prod_{i=0}^{n-1}x_{i} - 2 \sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}\right) t + \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}\right)^{2} \in \mathbb{Z}[t]$, we have that $x_{n}x_{n}' = \left(\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}\right)^{2}$. If $x_{n}$ is already the smaller of these roots, then we are done. Otherwise, we have a solution $(x_{0}, x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n-1}, x_{n}')$ to Equation \ref{eq:1} with $x_{n}' < \sum_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i} < x_{n}$. Reordering $x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n-1}, x_{n}'$ in increasing order, and then reapplying this reduction step a finite number of times, we eventually arrive at a solution of the desired form.

Now, given a solution $(x_{0}, x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n}) \in \mathbb{Z}_{\ge 1}^{n-1}$ to Equation \ref{eq:1} with $x_{1} \le \dotsb \le x_{n} \le \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} x_{i}$, we solve for $x_{0}$ and find that \begin{align*} x_{0} &=% \frac{\left(\sum_{i=1}^{n} x_{i}\right)^{2}}{\prod_{i=1}^{n}x_{i}} \le % 4\frac{\left(\sum_{i=1}^{n-1} x_{i}\right)^{2}}{\prod_{i=1}^{n}x_{i}} \le % 4\cdot% \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n-1} x_{i}}{x_{n}} \cdot \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n-1} x_{i}}{\prod_{i=1}^{n-1}x_{i}} \\ &= % 4\cdot% \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} \frac{x_{i}}{x_{n}} \cdot \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} \frac{1}{\prod_{\substack{1 \le j \le n-1 \\ j \ne i}} x_{j}} \le % 4\cdot (n-1)\cdot \frac{n-1}{\prod_{j=1}^{n-2} x_{j}}. \end{align*} Thus, if at least two of the numbers $x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n-2}$ are $\ge 2$, or at least one of the numbers $x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n-2}$ is $\ge 4$, we have that $x_{0} \le (n-1)^{2}$, and we are done. Otherwise, $(x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n})$ has either the form $(1, \dotsc, 1, 1, x_{n-1}, x_{n})$ with $x_{n-1} \le x_{n} \le n-2 + x_{n-1}$, or the form $(1, \dotsc, 1, 2, x_{n-1}, x_{n})$ with $2 \le x_{n-1} \le x_{n} \le n-1 + x_{n-1}$, or the form $(1, \dotsc, 1, 3, x_{n-1}, x_{n})$ with $3 \le x_{n-1} \le x_{n} \le n + x_{n-1}$.

In each of these cases, one can work out directly that $x_{0} \le n^{2}$. ETA: For example, if $(x_{1}, \dotsc, x_{n})$ has the form $(1, \dotsc, 1, 3, x_{n-1}, x_{n})$ with $3 \le x_{n-1} \le x_{n} \le n + x_{n-1}$, then \begin{align*} x_{0} &=% \frac{(n+x_{n-1}+x_{n})^{2}}{3x_{n-1}x_{n}} \\ &=% \frac{n^{2}}{3x_{n-1}x_{n}} + \frac{2}{3}\left(\frac{1}{x_{n-1}} + \frac{1}{x_{n}}\right)n + \frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{x_{n-1}}{x_{n}} + 2 + \frac{x_{n}}{x_{n-1}}\right) \\ &\le% \frac{n^{2}}{27} + \frac{2}{3} \cdot \frac{2}{3} \cdot n + \frac{1}{3}\left(1 + 2 + \frac{n + x_{n-1}}{x_{n-1}}\right) \\ &\le% \frac{n^{2}}{27} + \frac{4}{9} n + \frac{1}{3}\left(3 + \frac{n}{3} + 1\right) \\ &\le% \frac{n^{2}}{27} + \frac{5}{9} n + \frac{4}{3} \\ &\le% n^{2} \quad \text{for $n \ge 2$}. \end{align*}

Thank you again to Will Jagy for pointing out a missed case.

2
On

Some examples to get you started; $n=3,$ where I am printing only the fundamental solutions.

Amusing: for fundamental with $x_1 \geq x_2 \geq .... \geq x_n \geq 1,$ apparently $x_1 \leq 5n + 10.$ Maybe provable, maybe not. The gound solution with maximal $x_1$ comes out $a=1$ and $x_1 = 5n+10, x_2 = 4n + 8; x_3 = 5, x_4 = x_5 = x_6 = ... = x_n = 1$ Your equation becomes $100 (n+2)^2 = 100 ( n+2)^2 $

With $x \geq y \geq z \geq 1$ and $(x+y+z)^2 = a xyz,$ a fundamental solution also satisfies $ayz \geq 2(x+y+z).$ Each fundamental solution should lead to a tree of solution triples, but this needs proof. In Hurwitz (1907) this is Satz 5. Meanwhile, the earliest illustration is the tree of Markov Triples, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_number

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$ For $n=3.$ Just the fundamental solutions.

jagy@phobeusjunior:~$ ./mse 
    x:  1    y:  1    z:  1   a:   9 coprime
    x:  2    y:  1    z:  1   a:   8 coprime
    x:  3    y:  2    z:  1   a:   6 coprime
    x:  3    y:  3    z:  3   a:   3 gcd(x,y,z):  3
    x:  4    y:  2    z:  2   a:   4 gcd(x,y,z):  2
    x:  5    y:  4    z:  1   a:   5 coprime
    x:  6    y:  4    z:  2   a:   3 gcd(x,y,z):  2
    x:  8    y:  4    z:  4   a:   2 gcd(x,y,z):  4
    x:  9    y:  6    z:  3   a:   2 gcd(x,y,z):  3
    x:  9    y:  9    z:  9   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z):  9
    x: 16    y:  8    z:  8   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z):  8
    x: 18    y: 12    z:  6   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z):  6
    x: 25    y: 20    z:  5   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z):  5

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

$n=4.$ Here we begin to see that the smallest variable, here $w,$ must be very small. In Hurwitz, the Tabelle on page 194, shows that $x_j = 1$ for $j \geq 5.$ That's an important part of how he made the table, hand calculations.

jagy@phobeusjunior:~$ ./mse 
    x:  1    y:  1    z:  1    w:  1   a:   16 coprime
    x:  2    y:  2    z:  1    w:  1   a:   9 coprime
    x:  2    y:  2    z:  2    w:  2   a:   4 gcd(x,y,z,w):  2
    x:  3    y:  1    z:  1    w:  1   a:   12 coprime
    x:  4    y:  2    z:  1    w:  1   a:   8 coprime
    x:  4    y:  3    z:  3    w:  2   a:   2 coprime
    x:  4    y:  4    z:  3    w:  1   a:   3 coprime
    x:  4    y:  4    z:  4    w:  4   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z,w):  4
    x:  5    y:  2    z:  2    w:  1   a:   5 coprime
    x:  6    y:  2    z:  2    w:  2   a:   3 gcd(x,y,z,w):  2
    x:  6    y:  3    z:  2    w:  1   a:   4 coprime
    x:  6    y:  4    z:  1    w:  1   a:   6 coprime
    x:  6    y:  6    z:  3    w:  3   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z,w):  3
    x:  8    y:  4    z:  2    w:  2   a:   2 gcd(x,y,z,w):  2
    x:  8    y:  5    z:  5    w:  2   a:   1 coprime
    x:  9    y:  6    z:  2    w:  1   a:   3 coprime
    x: 10    y:  5    z:  4    w:  1   a:   2 coprime
    x: 10    y:  8    z:  1    w:  1   a:   5 coprime
    x: 10    y: 10    z:  9    w:  1   a:   1 coprime
    x: 12    y:  6    z:  4    w:  2   a:   1 gcd(x,y,z,w):  2
    x: 12    y:  8    z:  3    w:  1   a:   2 coprime
    x: 15    y: 10    z:  3    w:  2   a:   1 coprime
    x: 18    y:  9    z:  8    w:  1   a:   1 coprime
    x: 21    y: 14    z:  6    w:  1   a:   1 coprime
    x: 30    y: 24    z:  5    w:  1   a:   1 coprime

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

$n=5$

  x:  1  y:  1  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 25 coprime
  x:  2  y:  1  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 18 coprime
  x:  2  y:  2  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  a: 8 coprime
  x:  3  y:  3  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 9 coprime
  x:  3  y:  3  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  a: 2 coprime
  x:  4  y:  1  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 16 coprime
  x:  4  y:  3  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  4  y:  3  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x:  4  y:  4  z:  4  w:  2  t:  2  a: 1 gcd:  2
  x:  5  y:  2  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 10 coprime
  x:  5  y:  5  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  6  y:  2  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  a: 6 coprime
  x:  6  y:  3  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 8 coprime
  x:  7  y:  4  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 7 coprime
  x:  7  y:  7  z:  3  w:  3  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  8  y:  2  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  a: 2 gcd:  2
  x:  8  y:  4  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x:  8  y:  5  z:  5  w:  1  t:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x:  9  y:  3  z:  3  w:  2  t:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x:  9  y:  4  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  9  y:  6  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 6 coprime
  x:  9  y:  8  z:  4  w:  2  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 10  y:  5  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 11  y: 11  z:  9  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 12  y:  4  z:  4  w:  3  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 12  y:  6  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  a: 1 gcd:  2
  x: 12  y:  6  z:  4  w:  1  t:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 12  y:  8  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x: 14  y:  7  z:  4  w:  2  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 15  y: 10  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 15  y: 12  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  a: 5 coprime
  x: 16  y:  9  z:  9  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 18  y: 12  z:  3  w:  2  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 20  y: 10  z:  8  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 21  y: 12  z:  7  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 24  y: 16  z:  6  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 35  y: 28  z:  5  w:  1  t:  1  a: 1 coprime

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

$n=6. $ There is still a single fundamental solution with gcd 2. All the others have $x_6=1$

  x:  1  y:  1  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 36 coprime
  x:  2  y:  2  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 16 coprime
  x:  3  y:  2  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  u:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  3  y:  3  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x:  4  y:  3  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 6 coprime
  x:  4  y:  4  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 9 coprime
  x:  4  y:  4  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  u:  2  a: 1 gcd:  2
  x:  4  y:  4  z:  4  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x:  5  y:  1  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 20 coprime
  x:  5  y:  5  z:  4  w:  4  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  6  y:  2  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 12 coprime
  x:  6  y:  3  z:  3  w:  3  t:  2  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  6  y:  6  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  7  y:  2  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 7 coprime
  x:  8  y:  2  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x:  8  y:  4  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 8 coprime
  x:  8  y:  6  z:  6  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  8  y:  8  z:  3  w:  3  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  9  y:  3  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x:  9  y:  3  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x:  9  y:  8  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x:  9  y:  8  z:  4  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 10  y:  5  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 4 coprime
  x: 12  y:  4  z:  3  w:  2  t:  2  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 12  y:  6  z:  2  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 12  y:  8  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 6 coprime
  x: 12  y: 12  z:  9  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 14  y:  7  z:  2  w:  2  t:  2  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 14  y:  7  z:  4  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 15  y:  6  z:  5  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 15  y: 10  z:  2  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 3 coprime
  x: 16  y:  8  z:  4  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 18  y: 12  z:  3  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 2 coprime
  x: 18  y: 14  z:  7  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 20  y: 16  z:  1  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 5 coprime
  x: 21  y: 14  z:  3  w:  2  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 22  y: 11  z:  8  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 27  y: 18  z:  6  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime
  x: 40  y: 32  z:  5  w:  1  t:  1  u:  1  a: 1 coprime

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

0
On

Here is the list of fundamental solutions for $n=9.$ For the first time (lowest $n$), all have $ \gcd( x_1, x_2, x_3, x_4, x_5, x_6, x_7, x_8, x_9) =1.$ For you, the point of the list is that the coefficient (I call it $a$ ) occurs as the $a$ value for fundamental solutions. In time, enough inequalities may (probably will) show that all $a \leq n^2.$ With my order $x_1 \geq x_2 \geq x_3 \geq \cdots \geq x_9 \geq 1$ the other reasonable conjecture is that $x_1 \leq 5n+10.$

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

  1   x1: 11 x2: 11 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 12 x2:  5 x3:  5 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 15 x2: 15 x3:  9 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 16 x2: 11 x3: 11 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 16 x2:  4 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 16 x2:  9 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 18 x2: 16 x3:  8 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 18 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 20 x2: 10 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 20 x2:  8 x3:  5 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 22 x2: 11 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 27 x2: 12 x3:  9 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 28 x2: 14 x3:  8 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 30 x2: 20 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 36 x2: 24 x3:  6 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 49 x2: 45 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1: 55 x2: 44 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  5 x4:  5 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1:  6 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1:  8 x2:  4 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  1   x1:  9 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  2 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
  2   x1: 10 x2:  9 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1: 15 x2:  5 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1: 18 x2:  6 x3:  6 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1: 18 x2:  9 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1: 20 x2: 10 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1: 27 x2: 18 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  2 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  2 x7:  2 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  3 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  8 x2:  6 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  8 x2:  7 x3:  7 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  2   x1:  9 x2:  4 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
  3   x1: 12 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  3   x1: 15 x2:  5 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  3   x1: 24 x2: 16 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  3   x1:  4 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  3   x1:  8 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  3   x1:  9 x2:  9 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
  4   x1: 12 x2:  3 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
  4   x1: 16 x2:  8 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
  4   x1:  4 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
  4   x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
  5   x1: 35 x2: 28 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 5 
  6   x1: 12 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
  6   x1: 21 x2: 14 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
  6   x1:  6 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
  8   x1: 14 x2:  7 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
  8   x1:  4 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
  8   x1:  9 x2:  8 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
  9   x1:  7 x2:  7 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 9 
 10   x1: 10 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 10 
 10   x1:  8 x2:  5 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 10 
 11   x1: 11 x2:  4 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 11 
 15   x1:  5 x2:  3 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 15 
 18   x1:  2 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 18 
 18   x1:  9 x2:  2 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 18 
 24   x1:  3 x2:  2 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 24 
 32   x1:  8 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 32 
 36   x1:  4 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 36 
 50   x1:  2 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 50 
 81   x1:  1 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 81 

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$

  S = x1 + x2 + x3 + x4 + x5 + x6 + x7 + x8 + x9
  P = x1 * x2 * x3 * x4 * x5 * x6 * x7 * x8 * x9
   S^2 = a * P
   fundamental:
   x1 >= x2 >= x3 >= x4 >= x5 >= x6 >= x7 >= x8 >= x9 >= 1  AND
   a*P >=  2*x1 * S 

 x1:  1 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 81 
 x1:  2 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 50 
 x1:  2 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 18 
 x1:  2 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  2 x7:  2 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  3 x2:  2 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 24 
 x1:  3 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  4 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 36 
 x1:  4 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
 x1:  4 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1:  4 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
 x1:  5 x2:  3 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 15 
 x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
 x1:  5 x2:  5 x3:  5 x4:  5 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1:  6 x2:  3 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
 x1:  6 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1:  7 x2:  7 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 9 
 x1:  8 x2:  1 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 32 
 x1:  8 x2:  4 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1:  8 x2:  5 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 10 
 x1:  8 x2:  6 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  8 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1:  8 x2:  7 x3:  7 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  9 x2:  2 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 18 
 x1:  9 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  2 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1:  9 x2:  4 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1:  9 x2:  8 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
 x1:  9 x2:  9 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1: 10 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 10 
 x1: 10 x2:  9 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 11 x2:  4 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 11 
 x1: 11 x2: 11 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 12 x2:  2 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1: 12 x2:  3 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
 x1: 12 x2:  4 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
 x1: 12 x2:  5 x3:  5 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 14 x2:  7 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 8 
 x1: 15 x2:  5 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 15 x2:  5 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1: 15 x2: 15 x3:  9 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 16 x2:  4 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 16 x2:  8 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 4 
 x1: 16 x2:  9 x3:  3 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 16 x2: 11 x3: 11 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 18 x2:  6 x3:  4 x4:  3 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 18 x2:  6 x3:  6 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 18 x2:  9 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 18 x2: 16 x3:  8 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 20 x2:  8 x3:  5 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 20 x2: 10 x3:  2 x4:  2 x5:  2 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 20 x2: 10 x3:  4 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 21 x2: 14 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 6 
 x1: 22 x2: 11 x3:  4 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 24 x2: 16 x3:  2 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 3 
 x1: 27 x2: 12 x3:  9 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 27 x2: 18 x3:  3 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 2 
 x1: 28 x2: 14 x3:  8 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1
 x1: 30 x2: 20 x3:  3 x4:  2 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 35 x2: 28 x3:  1 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 5 
 x1: 36 x2: 24 x3:  6 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 49 x2: 45 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1 
 x1: 55 x2: 44 x3:  5 x4:  1 x5:  1 x6:  1 x7:  1 x8:  1 x9:  1  a: 1

$$ \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc \bigcirc $$