Can we find a palindrome for more than $5$ factors?

105 Views Asked by At

For positive integers $a,b$ and $k$ , define $$p(a,b,k):=\prod_{j=1}^k (a(j-1)+b)$$ That is the product of the first $k$ numbers in the arithmetic progression $an+b$ starting with $b$

Can $p(a,b,k)$ be a palindrome (in base $10$) for $k\ge 6$ ? Are there more than $2$ palindromes for $k= 5$ ?

In the case $k=4$ , there are still many palindromes.

For $a,b\le 10^4$ , they are summarized in this table :

4   [7, 9, 11, 13]  9009
4   [12, 14, 16, 18]  48384
4   [1, 5, 9, 13]  585
4   [91, 101, 111, 121]  123444321
4   [11, 26, 41, 56]  656656
4   [26, 42, 58, 74]  4686864
4   [1023, 1073, 1123, 1173]  1445949495441
4   [9901, 10001, 10101, 10201]  10203040404030201
4   [127, 245, 363, 481]  5432772345
4   [1059, 1407, 1755, 2103]  5499287829945
4   [471, 961, 1451, 1941]  1274785874721
4   [55, 583, 1111, 1639]  58388088385
4   [13, 543, 1073, 1603]  12141614121
4   [1864, 2428, 2992, 3556]  48152399325184
4   [8841, 9497, 10153, 10809]  9214414224144129
4   [77, 1111, 2145, 3179]  583341143385

But for $5\le k\le 20$ and the same range for $a,b$ , there are just the following two solutions :

5   [31, 33, 35, 37, 39]  51666615
5   [182, 362, 542, 722, 902]  23255355355232

For $k\ge 5$ , the following can be said about the difference $a$ :

  • If $a$ is coprime to $10$ , one of the factors of the product must be divisible by $5$ and the product is even, hence divisible by $10$. A palindrome is hence impossible.

  • If $a$ is even , but not divisible by $5$ , one of the factors must be divisible by $5$ , hence the only possible palindrome is $5\cdots 5$, in particular all factors must be odd.

But that's it. I found no more useful necessary conditions for a palindrome.