This seems to be a very simple question but surely because there is an infinite way of writing a=1 and b=2 in so many different forms, can you ever disprove a proof or prove something in more than one way. Thanks
2026-04-13 13:38:31.1776087511
On
Can you ever disprove a proof or prove something in more than one way
1.7k Views Asked by Bumbble Comm https://math.techqa.club/user/bumbble-comm/detail At
2
There are 2 best solutions below
0
On
if "disprove a proof" means "find out that a statement is false", there are many ways to do it too. The first ones I can think of are:
- to find an explicit counterexample to the statement. If you state "there are no solution to the equation $|{3^m-2^n}|=1; m,n\ge 2$", I may say $3^2-2^3=1$.
- to find a contradiction, that is, show that if the statement were true you would derive a result which is certainly false.
- a variant of contradiction is to show that there cannot exist a minimum or a maximum value for a finite set; the Euclidean proof that the prime numbers are infinite works in this way.
- still another variant is to show that a property which is necessary is not achieved. Euler showed that all nodes in the graph for a reentrant path must have an even number of edges exiting from them; the graph for Königsberg walk had four nodes with an odd number of edges, so it could not be reentrant.
You cannot disprove a proof. Instead, what you are doing is proving that said proof is not a proof.
And yes, there are generally many ways to prove something. At the simplest, most things can be proven directly, by induction, or by contradiction.