Center of mass question

65 Views Asked by At

I am not sure how to set the limits for this question:

Let (x¯, y¯) be the center of mass of the triangle with vertices at (−2, 0), (0, 1), (2, 0) and uniform density δ = 1.

a) Write an integral formula for y¯. Do not evaluate the integral(s), but write explicitly the integrand and limits of integration.

b) Find x¯

For a, I did

1/2*$\iint_{-2}^{2} int_{0.5x+1}^{-0.5x+1}y \,dydx$

So the limits for x are -0.5x+1 and 0.5x+1, and y are 2 and -2.

In the correct answer:

1/2*$\iint_{0}^{1} int_{2y-2}^{2-2y}y \,dxdy$

So the limits for x are 2-2y and 2y-2 and y are 1 and 0.

Why are my limits incorrect?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

When picking integration bounds, the point is just that your bounds should describe the correct triangle.

Your amounts to saying: For each $x$ satisfying $-2 \le x \le 2$, I'll cover all $y$ satisfying $1+x/2 \le y \le 1-x/2$. Here is a picture of the points that satisfy your conditions: enter image description here It's kind of related to the triangle you want (uses some of the same boundary lines) but it's not the correct triangle.


You could fix your answer by instead saying: For each $x$ satisfying $-2 \le x \le 0$, we need to cover all $y$ satisfying $0 \le y \le 1+x/2$, and in addition for each $x$ satisfying $0 \le x \le 2$ we need to cover all $y$ satisfying $0 \le y \le 1 - x/2$. That would give the answer

$$\frac 1 2 \left(\int_{-2}^0 \int_0^{1+x/2} y dy dx + \int_0^2 \int_0^{1-x/2} y dy dx\right)$$

The above is a correct answer to the problem, but it's kind of messy: If we choose $x$ first and $y$ afterward (i.e. making $x$ the outer integral), then the maximum value of $y$ is defined by a different line depending on whether $x<0$ or $x>0$, which is why we needed to break into two integrals.

We can get a simpler-looking answer by instead choosing $y$ first and $x$ afterward (making $y$ the outer integral). In that case, the triangle we want has $y$ values $0 \le y \le 1$, and for each $y$ value we need to cover all $x$ satisfying $2y-2 \le x \le 2-2y$. That gives the answer $$\frac 1 2 \int_0^1 \int_{2y-2}^{2-2y} y dx dy.$$ Note this version only has one integral to compute, and note that the $dx$ integral is on the outside this time.

Both of the formulas I've given are correct answers to this problem. If you needed to actually compute the final value $y^-$, you could use whichever integral formula you prefer; they'll both come out to the same result.