Central Forces in Spherical Polar Coordinates

322 Views Asked by At

I know this isn’t how StackExchange works, but I needed to comment on the answer to this question and I don’t have enough reputation to do so (or enough time to gain enough).

I intended to ask why it is sufficient to show only that the $\phi$ component is equal to $0$. I understand how to show that $r^2\dot\phi\sin^2\theta$ being constant means that the $\phi$ component is $0$, but I couldn’t work out how to show that this also means the $\theta$ component is equal to $0$, despite the answer to the linked question implying that the $\theta$ component doesn’t necessarily have to equal $0$.

Also, I’m aware that this question probably counts as a duplicate, but I couldn’t see another way of asking without somehow gaining 42 reputation in less than two hours.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

It's given in the problem that the acceleration is radial only, so we know acceleration in the $\phi$ and $\theta$ components are both $0$. As it turns out, to solve the problem, all we need is that acceleration in the $\phi$ component is $0$; the fact that acceleration in the $\theta$ component is $0$ is extraneous information.