Let $ \alpha \le 0 $ and $\sigma > 0$ .
I want to choose a contour, including $ [\sigma - iR, \sigma+iR] $ , such that i can apply Cauchy's Residue theorem and evaluate:
$$ \lim_{R \rightarrow \infty} \int\limits_{\sigma - iR}^{ \sigma+iR } \frac{\exp(\alpha z)}{(z^2 + 1)} dz$$
by contour integration. The case for $\alpha > 0 $ is nice i think, as you can use a semi-circle, but i cant seem to find a suitable contour for this case.
EDIT: to be specific when we use a semi-circle then the integral over the circular path tends to zero in the limit for $\alpha > 0 $ , but this does not seem to happen in the above case.
You can choose a semicircle in the half-plane $\operatorname{Re} z \geqslant \sigma$. Then $e^{\alpha z}$ is bounded on the contour - $\operatorname{Re} (\alpha z) = \alpha\operatorname{Re} z \leqslant \alpha\sigma \leqslant 0$, and $\lvert e^{\alpha z}\rvert = e^{\operatorname{Re} (\alpha z)}$ - and the integral over the semicircle tends to $0$ for $R \to \infty$. Since the contour encloses no singularity, the contour integral is $0$, and hence
$$\int_{\sigma - i\infty}^{\sigma+i\infty} \frac{e^{\alpha z}}{z^2+1}\,dz = 0$$
for $\sigma > 0$ and $\alpha \leqslant 0$.
It is worth noting that
$$I(\alpha) = \int_{\sigma-i\infty}^{\sigma+i\infty} \frac{e^{\alpha z}}{z^2+1}\,dz = \begin{cases}\quad 0 &, \alpha \leqslant 0\\ 2\pi i\sin \alpha &, \alpha \geqslant 0 \end{cases}$$
does not depend smoothly on $\alpha$, although the integrand does. That should, however, not be too surprising since the differentiated integrand $\dfrac{ze^{\alpha z}}{z^2+1}$ is not integrable anymore, and the non-differentiability in $0$ manifests itself by the need to switch the half-plane in which the contour is closed to have the integral over the auxiliary part tend to $0$.