Coproduct of abelian groups

357 Views Asked by At

In the comments to this answer, Martin Brandenburg told me that it is possible to derive the element structure of the coproduct $A\oplus B$ of two abelian groups $A$ and $B$, by knowing that such a coproduct exists and by using the universal property. In particular, it is not necessary to use an explicit description of it. Since I usually have to deal with situations in which I know the existence of a universal solution to a certain question, but I don't know how to explicitly describe it, I would be glad to learn how this could be done in this case.

For me, given two abelian groups $A,B$ their coproduct is an abelian group $Z$ together with two group homomorphisms $j_A:A\to Z$ and $j_B :B\to Z$ which is universal with respect to this property. That is to say, such that for any other abelian group $C$ together with two morphisms of abelian groups $f:A\to C$ and $g:B\to C$, there exists a unique morphism of abelian groups $\nabla(f,g):Z\to C$ such that $\nabla(f,g)\circ j_A = f$ and $\nabla(f,g)\circ j_B = g$.

I tried to solve the exercise Martin left to me. First of all, since we are in the category of abelian groups, we have the zero morphism and hence I can consider $\nabla(id_A,0):Z\to A$ and $\nabla(0,id_B):Z\to B$.

Now I need to assume that I know that products in the category of abelian groups exist and that they can be realized as the product of the underlying sets together with the component-wise composition law. Thanks to these assumptions, I know that there exists a unique group homomorphism $\Phi:Z \to A\times B$ such that $\pi_A\circ\Phi=\nabla(id_A,0)$ and $\pi_B \circ \Phi = \nabla(0,id_B)$. By composing, I can consider $i_A:=\Phi\circ j_A:A\to A\times B$ and $i_B:=\Phi\circ j_B :B \to A\times B$. Since $\pi_A\circ\Phi\circ j_A = id_A$ and $\pi_B\circ\Phi\circ j_B = id_B$, both $i_A$ and $i_B$ are injective (and $j_A$ and $j_B$ as well).

At this point I stopped because I realized that I am not "describing the element structure" of $A\oplus B$. I am showing that $A\oplus B$ is isomorphic to $A\times B$ with component-wise composition law (next step would have been to use the universal property of $A\times B$ to show that there exists a unique group homomorphism $\Psi:A\times B\to Z$ such that $\Psi \circ \Delta(id_A,0) = j_A$ and $\Psi \circ \Delta(0,id_B) = j_B$ and then proving that, by uniqueness and the explicit description of $A\times B$, $\Phi$ and $\Psi$ are each other inverses). Thus, I am providing an explicit realization of $A\oplus B$, which is not what has been asked me.

Can anybody suggest me a different approach?