Does every continuous map between compact metrizable spaces lift to the Cantor set?

468 Views Asked by At

I'm interested in the universal properties of the Cantor set. It is well-know that the Cantor set $2^\mathbb{N}$ is "universal" in the category of metrizable compact spaces, in the sense that every compact metrizable space is a quotient of $2^\mathbb{N}$ (although the quotient map is not unique).

My main question is: Does every continuous map $f:K_1\to K_2$ between compact metrizable spaces lift to a continuous map of the Cantor space (together with some quotient maps)?

If so, what else can we say about such a lift? For example, if $f$ is a homeomorphism, can we lift it to a homeomorphism of the Cantor set? What about group actions: Does every action of a group on a compact metrizable space by homeomorphisms lift to an action on the Cantor set (with a quotient map)?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

The answer to your main question is yes. Let $f\colon K_1\to K_2$ be a map between compact metrizable spaces. Let $q_1\colon C_1\to K_1$ and $q_2\colon C_2\to K_2$ be quotient maps, where $C_1$ and $C_2$ are Cantor spaces. Then the following diagram commutes.

$$\require{AMScd} \begin{CD} C_1 @>\mathrm{incl.}>> C_1 \uplus C_2\\ @V q_1 V V @VV (f\;\circ\; q_1)\;\cup\; q_2 V\\ K_1 @>>f> K_2 \end{CD}$$

Here $C_1\uplus C_2$ denotes the disjoint union (or coproduct) of $C_1$ and $C_2$. Note that $C_1\uplus C_2$ is itself a Cantor space. The map $(f\circ q_1)\cup q_2$ is automatically a quotient map since it's a surjective map between compact Hausdorff spaces.

The answer is also yes for actions of finite groups. Given a finite group $G=\{g_1,\ldots,g_n\}$ of homeomorphisms of a compact metric space $K$, let $q\colon C\to K$ be a quotient map, and consider the map $q'\colon G\times C\to K$ defined by $$ q'(g,x) \;=\; (g\circ q)(x). $$ Note that $G\times C$ is a Cantor space, being the product of a Cantor space with a finite set, and the map $q'$ is clearly a quotient map. If we let $G$ act on $G\times C$ by $g_1(g_2,x) = (g_1g_2,x)$, then the map $q'$ is equivariant.

Note that this argument actually works for any topological group $G$ such that $G\times C$ is itself a Cantor space. In particular, it works whenever $G$ is a separable profinite group.

Edit: I originally had an argument that it works for any group $G$ that embeds into a profinite group, but I no longer think that argument is correct. Thus, I have no idea whether the statement holds even for the case $G=\mathbb{Z}$.