Exercise 1(d) from Courant

235 Views Asked by At

I'm having trouble understanding this "hint" in the back of (the first volume of) Courant's Differential and Integral Calculus text, which I'm just starting:

One of the "challenging" Chapter 1 exercises asks you to prove that $x = \sqrt{2} + \sqrt[3]{2}$ is irrational; the hint says to "Show that $x$ satisfies an equation of the type

$$ x^6 + a_1x^5 + ...+ a_6 = 0 $$

where $a_1, ..., a_6$ are integers; prove that $x$ is then either irrational or an integer.

I guess I don't really understand what one is supposed to be "showing" here - and even if one does in fact "show" what Courant is expecting you to "show", musn't $x$ necessarily be rational according to Gauss' lemma?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

Hint: Make the polynomial, perhaps by starting from $x-\sqrt{2}=\sqrt[3]{2}$ and cubing both sides.

By the Rational Roots Theorem any rational root will have to be of the shape $\frac{c}{d}$, where $c$ is a divisor of $a_6$ and $d$ is a divisor of $a_0$, in this case $1$. There is only a finite number of candidates. If none works, you will know that the sixth degree polynomial has no rational roots.

Remark: You asked about one particular approach to the problem. A slightly different way is to let $x=\sqrt{2}+\sqrt[3]{2}$.

We have $x-\sqrt{2}=\sqrt[3]{2}$. Cube both sides. We get $x^3-3\sqrt{2}x^2+6x-2\sqrt{2}=2$.

Solving for $\sqrt{2}$ we find that $$\sqrt{2}=\frac{x^3+6x-2}{3x^2+2}.$$ If $x$ was rational, then, from the above expression. $\sqrt{2}$ would be rational. But it isn't. So $x$ cannot be rational.

However, what you are intended to do is to write $x^3+6x-2=(3x^2+2)\sqrt{2}$, square both sides, and simplify. You then get the degree $6$ equation with integer coefficients mentioned in the book.

0
On

By Gauss Lemma, if the root is a rational, it must be an integer, and you can show that your $x$ is not an integer. And hence, it cannot be rational.