Has this problem been studied?

103 Views Asked by At

Today in Italy all students under 18 faced with a test used to establish the quality of the schools they are in. I read one of the question (a mathematical question, of course!) that make me thing for a while. Here is the question:

"Prove or disprove that $n^2 + n + 1$ is a prime number for all positive integers n."

After a while, you are easily convinced that there are some $n$ such that $n^2+n+1$ is not prime. Indeed, taking $n=4$, we get $n^2+n+1 = 21 = 3 \cdot 7$, which is not prime.

This reading made me think about this problem:

What properties do all $n$, such that $n^2+n+1$ is prime, share?

or equivalently

What properties do all $n$, such that $n^2+n+1$ is not prime, share?

The problem has a really simple formulation and then I start wondering that someone already studied this. Is it true? Are there some references about it?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Questions about prime numbers and polynomials along the lines of your first question tend to be deep, and consequently very hard. One such question, a special case of the Bunyakovsky conjecture, asks whether the polynomial $n^2+1$ assumes infinitely many prime values; we don't have an answer. The current state of mathematical understanding is far removed from being able to answer your first question.

Your second question is easier to attack: we can classify some of the ways in which the polynomial $n^2+n+1$ fails to output primes, using modular arithmetic. More specifically, if you can find a number $d$ and a root of the polynomial $n^2+n+1$ modulo $d$ then you have found an infinite (linear) family of outputs of the polynomial which are not prime. For example,

  1. $n\equiv1\bmod3\implies3\mid n^2 + n + 1$.
  2. $n\equiv 2\bmod7$ or $n\equiv4\bmod7$ $\implies7\mid n^2+n+1$.