How to decompose an ideal as intersection of simpler ideals?

111 Views Asked by At

We have $$I=\left(x^2+2y^2-3,y(x-y),y(y+1)(y-1)\right)\subset\mathbb{C}[x,y]$$ and I would like to decompose it as intersection of simpler ideals. How could I proceed?

For example, in this case, could I write $$I=(x^2+2y^2−3,y,y(y+1)(y−1))∩(x^2+2y^2−3,x−y,y(y+1)(y−1))\ ?$$ Then could I make other similar simplifications? Is it correct?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Here's a tool that may be helpful for this kind of stuff.

Proposition: Let $I,J,K$ be ideals of a ring $R$ with $J + K = R$. Then $$I + JK = (I + J)(I + K) = (I + J) \cap (I + K).$$

Proof: $(I+J)(I+K) = I^2 + I(J+K) + JK = I + JK$.

Edit: I probably should mention that the last equality is simply a special case of the fact that $IJ = I \cap J$ if $I + J = R$. You can check this using the previously proven rule for products: $IJ = ((I \cap J) + I)((I \cap J) + J) = (I \cap J) + IJ = I \cap J$.

0
On

Here's another hint.

After lots of work (at least for me), you find that you don't really need the last generator of the ideal, because $$ \frac{y}{3}\left(x^2+2y^2-3\right) + \left(\frac{y+x}3 \right)(y^2-yx) = y^3-y=y(y-1)(y+1). $$

Hence your ideal has two generators $$ I = (x^2+2y^2-3,y^2-yx). $$ The first factor is irreducible, but the second factor is not. Then geometrically, this correspond to the intersection of the circle (or ellipse?) given by $x^2+2y^2-3$ and the union of the lines $y=0$ and $y=x$. These intersection points are easily computed to be $(\pm \sqrt{3},0)$ and $(\pm 1, \pm 1)$. Hence your ideal should decompose as $$ (y,x-\sqrt{3})\cap (y,x+\sqrt 3) \cap (x-1,y-1) \cap (x+1,y+1). $$

This must be checked algebraically of course, since this kind of geometric reasoning is only valid up to radicals.

NB: It is a small lie that I found the relation above by myself. I asked Macaulay2 to give a set of minimal generators for the ideal. Then once I knew there was only two generators, it was not too hard to find the relation by experimentation.