How to solve $x=8\sin x$?

247 Views Asked by At

Been thinking about this for quite a while, I know $0$ is one of the answers but I just cannot figure out how can I find the others (not by plotting the graphs but working it out steps by steps), please someone help me.

Edit:

  1. Approximate form is also accepted.
  2. I think no prior knowledge to calculus is expected for this question.
  3. How can calculus be used to find the answer? (Sorry for asking this as I have only shallow understanding about calculus, is it that we differentiate it once? And what next?)
  4. I heard there are seven answers in total including $0$.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

OK in separate steps:

  1. $x=0$ is an obvious solution.

  2. x and $\sin(x)$ are both odd functions, so any solution $x = 8\sin(x)$ will also lead to the solution $-x = 8\sin(-x)$. So we only need to consider $x >0$.

  3. $|\sin(x)| < 1$, so for $x >8$ there can be no solution. Hence, with (2.), consider $8>x >0$. In this regime, we have 3 solutions $x≈2.7859$ and $x≈7.49775$ and $x≈7.95732$. [Are you fine with numerical solutions?] With (2.), the negative values are also solutions. Formally, since $f(x) = x - 8\sin(x)$ is convex at the solutions, there will be no other solutions which you have "missed".

So in total, you have 7 solutions and you need look no further.