If $f(x)=x^3-\lambda x$ then $\Big\{ x\in\mathbb R : \Big| \lim_{n\to \infty}f^n(x)\Big|<+\infty \Big\}$ is a Cantor set.

140 Views Asked by At

enter image description here

This problem is from An introduction to chaotic dynamical systems Robert L. Devaney
I've already prove (a) and (b) but i'm a bit confused about (c).
For (c) we can assume that $\lambda>4$, I have seen a similar post here but it did not helped me at all, i was thinking of a different approach.


$f$ has $3$ fixed points since $f(x)=x\iff x_0=0 $ or $x_1=-\sqrt{1+\lambda}$, or $x_2=\sqrt{1+\lambda}$, if we define $$ A=\Big\{ x\in\mathbb R : \Big| \lim_{n\to \infty}f^n(x)\Big|<+\infty \Big\}$$ then $A\subseteq [x_1,x_2]\Rightarrow A=\Big\{ x\in[x_1,x_2] : f^n(x)\nrightarrow \pm \infty \Big\}$ ,
But how can i continue from this point on?
Any suggestions?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Note that for all $x>\sqrt{\lambda+1}, f(x) > x$, and so $\lim_{n\to\infty}f^n(x)=\infty$. Similarly for $x < -\sqrt{\lambda+1}$.

So the interesting thing is the behaviour of $x\in[-\sqrt{\lambda+1}, \sqrt{\lambda+1}]$. The critical question is if $x$ starting in $[-\sqrt{\lambda+1}, \sqrt{\lambda+1}]$ ever leaves that interval. We first note that the interval contains a local min and a local max, located at $x=\pm\sqrt{\lambda/3}$ the minimum and maximum value reached evaluate to $\pm\lambda^{3/2}\frac{2}{3\sqrt3}$. So $\lambda$ will be large enough to make $x$ jump out of the interval for some value of $x$ if:

$$ \frac{2\lambda^{3/2}}{3\sqrt3} > \sqrt{\lambda+1} $$

This gives a critical value of $\lambda=3$. For larger values of $\lambda$, subintervals around $x=\pm\sqrt{\lambda/3}$ get mapped outside of the range $[-\sqrt{\lambda+1}, \sqrt{\lambda+1}]$. If we remove these 2 subintervals, since they will eventually go to $\pm\infty$, the 3 remaining subintervals all have $f$ increasing or decreasing monotonically between $-\sqrt{\lambda+1}$, and $\sqrt{\lambda+1}$. This is just our original interval again, so applying $f$ another time will remove another 2 subintervals from each of our 3 remaining intervals. Applying this process ad infinitum produces a Cantor set.