Implication of equations

221 Views Asked by At

Just an interesting question I saw online. :)


Is the following statement true or false?

$$\large \dfrac{ab}{c^2} + \dfrac{bc}{a^2} + \dfrac{ca}{b^2} = 3 \iff \dfrac{a + b}{c} + \dfrac{b + c}{a} + \dfrac{c + a}{b} \in \{-3; 6\}$$

$a + b + c \ne 0$

Edit: In case you don't know, $a, b, c$ can be negative numbers too.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Notice that the equality $\dfrac{ab}{c^2}+\dfrac{bc}{a^2}+\dfrac{ca}{b^2}=3$ implies that for $x=ab, y=bc, z=ca$:

$$x^3+y^3+z^3-3xyz=0\leftrightarrow (x+y+z)((x-y)^2+(y-z)^2+(z-x)^2)=0$$.

This in turn implies that either $ab+bc+ca=0 \hspace{0.3cm}(1)$ or $a=b=c \hspace{0.3cm}(2)$.

  • Case (1):

We easily find by applying (1) solved for $a+b, b+c, c+a $ respectively:

$$ \begin{align} &\frac{a+b}{c}=-\frac{ab}{c^2}\\ &\frac{c+b}{a}=-\frac{bc}{a^2}\\ &\frac{a+c}{b}=-\frac{ac}{b^2} \end{align} $$ and we finally find that $$\frac{a+b}{c}+\frac{c+b}{a}+\frac{a+c}{b}=-\frac{ab}{c^2} -\frac{bc}{a^2} -\frac{ac}{b^2}=-3$$

by the original equation.

  • Case(2): when $a=b=c$ it's easy to see that

$$\frac{a+b}{c}+\frac{c+b}{a}+\frac{a+c}{b}=6$$

That means that the values of the algebraic expression in question could be either -3 or 6 given the constraint above.

2
On

If $a,b,c$ are all positive then we have by Am-Gm:

$$\dfrac{ab}{c^2} + \dfrac{bc}{a^2} + \dfrac{ca}{b^2} \geq 3\sqrt[3]{\dfrac{ab}{c^2} \cdot \dfrac{bc}{a^2} \cdot \dfrac{ca}{b^2}} = 3$$

With eqaulity iff $ \dfrac{ab}{c^2} = \dfrac{bc}{a^2} = \dfrac{ca}{b^2}$ which is iff $a=b=c$ so the value of expression is $6$.


Now suppose not all are positive. Clearly not all numbers $a,b,c$ can be negative. Suppose $a$ is positive and $b$ negative.

Put $x=a/c$ and $y=b/c$, then we can rewrite starting equation like $$x^3y^3+x^3+y^3=3x^2y^2$$

If we put $m= xy<0$ and $k=x+y$ we get $$ m^3+k^3-3mk-3m^2=0\implies k=-m \;\;\;{\rm or} \;\;\;k^2-km+m^2=3m$$

We would like to know what is the value of $${(x+y)(xy+x+y+1)\over xy}-2$$ i.e. $$E:={k(m+k+1)\over m}-2$$

If $m=-k$ we get $E=-3$.

If $3m =k^2-km+m^2={k^2+m^2+(k-m)^2\over 2}\geq 0$, then $m\geq 0$ but this is a contradiction since $m<0$.