In a TVS, the cylinder generated by a cross section of an open set is an open set

36 Views Asked by At

Because the direct sum of two topological vector spaces (TVS) equipped with the product topology is automatically a TVS, I wonder whether the converse is true: the topology of a TVS is the same as the product topology of a pair of its complementary vector subspaces (equipped with the subspace topology).

I found that this statement is equivalent to this: in a TVS, the cylinder generated by a cross section of an open set is an open set. Formally, let $V$ be a TVS and $X,Y$ be a pair of its complementary vector subspaces. Then, $$\forall A\in\tau_V:\left(A\cap X\right)+Y\in\tau_V.$$

Intuitively this is true in $\mathbb R^n$. Can this be proved in any TVS?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Another way of asking the same question is "is every linear projection continuous?" That's not true. Here's a counter example.

Suppose we have a Hilbert space $H$. A one-dimensional subspace $V$ is spanned by the vector $v=(1,1/2,1/3,\ldots)$. To choose the complementary subspace, we pick a basis: first, make sure that the basis contains a sequence $v_1,v_2,\ldots$ converging to $v$, and then extend (by AC) arbitrarily to some set $B$ such that $B$ together with $v$ forms a basis for $H$. Then, the projection $H\to V$ which maps $B$ to $0$ is not continuous because it maps all $v_i$ to $0$ but maps $v$ to $v\ne0$.