Intersection of arbitrary union of compact subsets.

95 Views Asked by At

My textbooks asks to prove that arbitrary intersection of compact subsets in hausdorff space is again compact.

I've kinda found the counterexample $\bigcap_{1\leq x<2} [x,3]=(2,3]$, and can't find where I have mistaken.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

First: your intersection $\cap_{1 \le x < 2 }[x,3] = [2,3]$: The right is included in the left as $[2,3] \subset [x,3]$ for all $x < 2$. And if $p$ is in the left hand intersection, then $p \le 3$ is clear and if $p < 2$ would hold, $p$ would not be in the set $[\max(1,\frac{p+2}{2}), 3]$, which is a set the left hand set takes the intersection over, and this is a contradiction, so $p \ge 2$ and so $p \in [2,3]$. But it's good to try to come up with potential counterexamples and see what goes wrong.

Second, the statement is in fact true. As a hint: use that compact sets are closed (which uses the Hausdorffness!).