Is any finite power of a symmetric subset again symmetric?

31 Views Asked by At

Definition

A topological group is a group $(X,\,*,\,\cal T)$ equipped with a topology $\cal T$ with respect to which the functions $$ p:X\times X\ni (x_1,x_2)\longrightarrow x_1*x_2\in X\quad\text{and}\quad s:X\ni x\longrightarrow x^{-1}\in X $$ are continuous.

So we say that a neighborhood $V_0$ of $x_0\in X$ is symmetric if the identity holds $$ V_0=V^{-1}_0 $$ where we put $$ V^{-1}_0:=\{x\in X:x=y^{-1}\,\text{with }y\in V_0\} $$

So we observe that if $x\in V_0^n$ for any $n\in\Bbb N^+$ then there exists $\xi_1(x),\dots,\xi_n(x)\in V_0$ such that $$ x=\xi_1(x)*\dots*\xi_n(x) $$ so that if $x\in(V_0^n)^{-1}$ and so $x^{-1}\in V_0^n$ then there exists $\xi_1(x^{-1}),\dots,\xi_n(x^{-1})\in V_0$ such that $$ x=\big(\xi_n(x^{-1})\big)^{-1}*\dots*\big(\xi_1(x^{-1})\big)^{-1} $$ but $V_0$ is symmetric and thus $\xi\big(\xi_n(x^{-1})\big)^{-1},\dots,\big(\xi_1(x^{-1})\big)^{-1}\in V_0$ which proves that $x\in V_0^n$: so we conclude that $$ (V_0^n)^{-1}\subseteq V_0^n $$ Finally, we observe that $$ x^{-1}=\big(\xi_1(x)*\dots*\xi_n(x)\big)^{-1}=\big(\xi_n(x))^{-1}*\dots*\big(\xi_1(x))^{-1} $$ for any $x\in V_0^n$ but again $V_0$ is symmetric and so $\big(\xi_1(x)\big)^{-1},\dots,\big(\xi_n(x)\big)^{-1}\in V_0$ so that $x^{-1}\in V_0^n$ and thus $$ x=(x^{-1})^{-1}\in(V_0^n)^{-1} $$ which proves that $$ V_0^n\subseteq(V_0^n)^{-1} $$

So I ask if the result effectively holds and thus I ask if I well proved it or if it is possibile to prove it with more simple argumentations. So coulds someone help me, please?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

This has nothing to do with topology, let alone neighborhoods (I corrected the title of this post.) You simply proved that if a subset $V$ of a group satisfies $V=V^{-1}$, then $V^n=(V^n)^{-1}$.

(Notice in passing that $V\subset V^{-1}$ and $V^{-1}\subset V$ are equivalent, hence both equivalent to $V=V^{-1}$.)

Your proof can be written more succintly: since (for any subset $V$) $(V^n)^{-1}=(V^{-1})^n$, $$V=V^{-1}\Rightarrow V^n=(V^{-1})^n=(V^n)^{-1}.$$