Jacobian Determinant of Mobius Band

440 Views Asked by At

Where is my logic wrong in the paragraph below?

Consider the mobius band in the context of differential geometry. It isn't orientable so there must be two chart transition maps from a differentiable atlas for the mobius band such that they have differing sign for the Jacobian determinant. But the determinant is a continuous map and since its range in this case includes $0$ there must be a point $p=det^{-1}(0)$ on the mobius band such that in a nbhd of $p$ any two charts with intersecting domain are not admissible to the atlas for the mobius band. This would mean any atlas for a mobius band can not completely cover it, right?

EDIT: Sorry, to the people that read this prior to my edits. But, I believe I've formulated my question correctly at this point and hopefully there will be no more edits.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

The overlap of two charts need not be connected; the determinant of the overlap can be positive on one component and negative on another without vanishing. If the Möbius band is covered by two charts, the overlap cannot be connected (by your argument).

On the other hand, if the Möbius band is covered by three or more charts, then each overlap of two charts can be connected, but the overlap of a single chart with its "neighbors" needn't be connected.

As Jeff Weeks puts it in The Shape of Space, non-orientability is not a local property.