Joint mgf and Independence of $X$ and $Y-X$

406 Views Asked by At

The question is to find a joint mgf of $X$ and $Z=Y-X$, then determine if $X$ and $Z$ are independent, where $f(x,y)=6e^{-x-2y}I_{(0<x<y<\infty)}$.

I found mgf of $X$ and $Z$ by $$mgf_{X,Z}(s,t)=E(e^{sX+tZ})=E(e^{(s-t)X+tY})=\int_{0}^{\infty}{\int_{x}^{\infty}f(x,y)\,dy}\,dx=\frac{6}{(3-s)(2-t)}$$

My question is, does this have something to do with the independence of $X$ and $Z$? It seems $mgf_{X,Z}(s,t)=mgf_{X}(s)\cdot mgf_{Z}(t)$, but does that guarantee that $f(x,z)=f_{X}(x)f_{Z}(z)$ for all $x$ and $z$ ? I see a few answers that say "yes", but I can't find the proof or reason.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Okay, so I've never worked with joint MGFs but here's an alternative solution (which I try to relate to MGFs).

If $A$ and $B$ are independent, then we have \begin{align} M_{A,B} (s,t) &= \mathbb{E} (e^{sA+tB}) \\ &= \mathbb{E} (e^{sA} e^{tB}) \\& = \mathbb{E} (e^{sA}) \mathbb{E} (e^{tB}) \end{align}

Does the reverse hold? I don't know. My bet is "not necessarily", although if it does hold you can prove independence using this property.

The alternative solution is simply using the PDF. We have that $f_{X,Y} (x,y) = 6e^{-x-2y} I_{0<x<y<\infty}$. Note that $Z=Y-X \iff Y = Z+X$. Then: \begin{align} f_{X,Z}(x,z) &= f_{X,Y}(x,z+x) \\ &= 6e^{-3x-2z} I_{0<x<x+z<\infty} \\ &= 6e^{-3x-2z} I_{0<x<\infty} I_{0<z<\infty} \end{align}

We get the marginals:

\begin{align} f_{X} (x) &= \int_{0}^{\infty} f_{X,Z} (x,z) dz \\ &= 3e^{-3x}, \ 0<x<\infty \end{align}

Similarly for $Z$, $f_Z (z) = 2e^{-2z}$ for $0<z<\infty$. Therefore we can express the joint distribution as a product of the marginal distributions: \begin{align} f_{X,Z}(x,z) &= 6e^{-3x-2z} I_{0<x<\infty} I_{0<z<\infty} \\ &= \left(3e^{-3x} I_{0<x<\infty} \right) \left(2e^{-2z} I_{0<z<\infty} \right) \\ &= f_X (x) f_Z (z) \end{align}

Which is the definition of independence. $X$ and $Z$ are independent.