Knot complement conjecture in solid tori

312 Views Asked by At

Has the knot complement conjecture been proven for knots in solid tori?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

9
On

If the conjecture is what I think it is (i.e. knots are determined by their compliments), then not, at least when knots are considered up to isotopy. A solid torus is an exterior of the unknot, so take a Whitehead link and twist around one of the components. The exterior of this link stays the same, and it is the exterior of the second component in the solid torus. But the second component changes (because you are performing meridional twists in the solid torus), and in fact the second component becomes a different knot (more or less) each time you twist, so these different knots cannot be isotopic in the solid torus (as they are not isotopic in $S^3$). I don't know the answer if you consider knots up to homeomorphism. But surely the answer factors through the corresponding question for two-component links with one component an unknot.