Let $G=N\rtimes H$ and the conjugacy action of $H$ on $N$ divide $N$ in two orbits. Show $N$ is abelian (and more).

98 Views Asked by At

Given a finite group $G$, $N \trianglelefteq G$, and $H \leq G$, such that $G$ is the inner semidirect product of $N$ and $H$, and knowing that the conjugacy action of $H$ on $N$ divides $N$ in two orbits, prove that:

  1. There exists a prime $p$ such that any nontrivial element of $N$ has order $p$
  2. $N$ is abelian
  3. It doesn't exist $M \trianglelefteq G$ nontrivial and properly contained in $N$.

My solution for $(1)$: I know that $N$ is divided in two orbits, and since there's one orbit that contains only $1_G$, all the elements $n\in N:n \neq 1_G$ are in the same orbit, meaning that they all have the same order, since the action is the conjungancy one. It follows that the order of $N$ must be $p^\alpha$, $p$ prime. I've been stuck for some time on $(2)$ and $(3)$ though, so any hint would be really appreciated. Thanks.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Thanks to the hints given in the comment section, I've been able to solve the problem, and I'm posting here the solution for any future reference.

For $(3)$, if there was $M \leq N\,,\,M\neq N$ normal in $G$, it would mean that $h^{-1}mh \in M$ for every $h \in H$ and $m \in M$. But since $N$ is divided in only two orbits, it exists $x \in H$ such that $x^{-1}mx=n\,,\,n\in N - M$.

For $(2)$, I know that $|N|=p^\alpha$, and that there exists a normal subgroup of $X \leq N$ that has order $p^{\alpha-1}$, meaning that $N/X$ is abelian and $N' \leq X$. But $N'$ is characteristic in $N$, so for $(3)$ it must be trivial $\Rightarrow N$ is abelian.