$M_3$ is modular

117 Views Asked by At

I was checking if $M_3$ and $N_5$ are modular.
Diamond and Pentagon lattices
So first is pentagon lattice. I am checking whether $a\vee (b\wedge c)=(a\vee b)\wedge c$.

Now for $N_5$, we have $a\le c$. So
$a\vee(b\wedge c)=a\vee 0=a$ and $(a\vee b)\wedge c=1\wedge c=c$.

So $a\vee (b\wedge c)\ne (a\vee b)\wedge c$ and hence $N_5$ is not modular.

But $a,b,c$ are pairwise incomparable in $M_3$. Means no $a\le c$. So how can $M_3$ be modular?

I know I'm doing something wrong. Thanks for any help.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

You should use different letters for the variables.

We need to verify $x\lor(y\land z)=(x\lor y)\land z$ whenever $x,y,z\in M_3$ and $x\le z$.

You can easily check that the identity holds in any lattice if any two of $x,y,z$ coincide, or if $x=0$ or $z=1$.

Since in $M_3$ all the comparable pairs $x\le z$ with $x\ne z$ include either $0$ or $1$, indeed there's nothing else to check.