Munkres Lemma 58.4

94 Views Asked by At

Please see this question for Lemma 58.4.

I don't really understand how Munkres concludes so quickly (in the last paragraph) that $F\circ G$ is a path homotopy between $f_0\ast c$ and $c\ast f_1$ (and also that $H\circ (F\circ G)$ is a path homotopy between the two paths he mentions). I can certainly write everything out and see that it's indeed true, but I have a feeling that there is some obvious reason for it. For example, I don't know how he uses $F\circ \beta_0=f_0, F\circ \beta_1=f_1,F\circ \gamma_0=F\circ \gamma_1=c$. Do these equalities make the facts I mentioned clear somehow (they may come up in the direct proof, but maybe it's immediately clear from them that the compositions give the homotopies between the mentioned paths)?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

As stated in the proof $G:I\times I \rightarrow I\times I$ is a homotopy from $\beta_0 * \gamma_1$ to $\gamma_0 * \beta_1$. Now $F\circ G:I\times I \rightarrow X\times I$ is a homotopy of something surely. We want to show it is the path homotopy from $f_0*c$ to $c* f_1$. So we check the following using the equalities that you mentioned: $$F(G(s,0))=F(\beta_0*\gamma_1)=f_0*c$$ $$F(G(s,1))=F(\gamma_0*\beta_1)=c*f_1$$ $$F(G(0,t))=F(\beta_0(0))=F(0,0)=(f(0),0)=(f_0*c)(0)$$ $$F(G(1,t))=F(\beta_1(1))=F(1,1)=(f(1),1)=(c*f_1)(1). $$ Thus $F\circ G$ really is the homotopy we are looking for (from $f_0*c$ to $c* f_1$). To show $H\circ(F\circ G)$ is the desired homotopy we make the recall $f_0(s)=(f(s),0)$ thus $H\circ f_0=H(f(s),0)=h\circ f$ by the definition of $H$. Likewise $f_1(s)=(f(s),1)$ hence $H\circ f_1=H(f(s),1)=k\circ f$ by the definition of $H$ again. Thus we realize the equalities of Munkres' $$(H\circ f_0)*(H\circ c)=(h\circ f)*\alpha $$ $$(H\circ c)*(H\circ f_1)=\alpha *(k\circ f) .$$For the appropriate end points of the above paths we have $$((h\circ f)*\alpha)(0)=(h\circ f)(0)=h(x_0)=y_0=\alpha(0)=(\alpha*(k\circ f))(0) $$ $$((h\circ f)*\alpha)(1)=\alpha(1)=y_1=(k\circ f)(1)=(\alpha*(k\circ f))(1) $$Now to tie everything together, $H\circ(F\circ G):I\times I \rightarrow Y$ has the properties: $$H(F(G(s,0)))=H(f_0*c)=(H\circ f_0)*(H\circ c)=(h\circ f)*\alpha $$ $$H(F(G(s,1)))=H(c*f_1)=(H\circ c)*(H\circ f_1)=\alpha *(k\circ f)$$ $$H(F(G(0,t)))=H(f(0),0)=(h\circ f)(0)=h(x_0)=y_0$$ $$H(F(G(1,t)))=H(f(1),1)=(k\circ f)(1)=k(x_0)=y_1$$ and $H\circ (F\circ G)$ is the desired homotopy.