Nested descreasing intersection of nonempty covering compact sets is nonempty (check proof)

415 Views Asked by At

Proof that the nested descreasing intersection of nonempty covering compact sets is nonempty.

Let $$A_{1} \supset A_{2} \supset \cdots \supset A_{n} \supset \cdots$$ be a nested decreasing sequence of compacts. Suppose that $\displaystyle \bigcap A_{n} = \emptyset$. Take $U_{n} = A_{n}^{c}$, then $$\bigcup U_{n} = \bigcup A_{n}^{c} = \left(\bigcap A_{n}\right)^{c} = A_{1}.$$ Here, I'm thinking of $A_{1}$ as the main metric space. Since $\{U_{n}\}$ is an open covering of $A_{1}$, we can extract a finite subcovering, that is, $$A_{\alpha_{1}}^{c}\cup A_{\alpha_{2}}^{c} \cup \cdots \cup A_{\alpha_{m}}^{c} \supset A_{1}$$ or $$(A_{1}\setminus A_{\alpha_{1}})\cup(A_{1}\setminus A_{\alpha_{2}})\cup\cdots\cup(A_{1}\setminus A_{\alpha_{m}}) \supset A_{1}.$$ But, this is true only if $A_{\alpha_{i}} = \emptyset$ for some $i$, a contradiction.

Is correct?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

In my opinion, you should add a justification of the assertion according to which that$$(A_1\setminus A_{\alpha_1})\cup(A_1\setminus A_{\alpha_2})\cup\cdots\cup(A_1\setminus A_{\alpha_m})\supset A_1\tag1$$can only occur if $A_1=\emptyset$. This happens because$$(1)\iff A_{\alpha_1}\cap\cdots\cap A_{\alpha_m}=\emptyset,$$but$$A_{\alpha_1}\cap\cdots\cap A_{\alpha_m}=A_{\max\{\alpha_1,\ldots,\alpha_m\}}\neq\emptyset.$$